The Shoei Multitec is a full-face modular helmet offering greater officer-safety features. Photo: Shoei

The Shoei Multitec is a full-face modular helmet offering greater officer-safety features. Photo: Shoei

With the crop of quicker, more agile police motorcycles now arriving at law enforcement agencies, you would think helmet progression would be parallel. Agencies have hesitated to adopt advanced helmets such as Shoei's Multitec that are specifically designed for today's cycles.

The three-quarter face helmet was adequate when motor officers rode the Kawasaki KZ 1000 primarily because the full fairing offered additional protection. With newer bikes such as the Kawasaki Concours 14P, the variable windshield design sacrifices wind protection for aerodynamics. As a result, debris and other particulates hit the rider's face. One of the greatest officer-safety risks is the increased speed and acceleration that these new bikes can reach.

A study completed by the University of Southern California—sponsored by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA)—revealed some startling data. Of the collisions investigated in what was known as the Hurt Study, 68 percent of the time there was an impact on the face. A traditional three-quarter helmet issued to many of the nation's motor officers does not protect an officer's face. Aside from the obvious potential for facial injury during a crash, less dramatic injuries caused by debris or skin cancer must also be considered.

During my staff study in support of modular, full-face helmets, I uncovered some significant statistics. I compared the safety standards for helmets set by the U.S. Department of Transportation (DOT) and the Snell Memorial Foundation. The DOT sets minimum safety standards for helmets sold in the U.S. that are known as FMVSS (Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard) 218. Snell sets voluntary standards.

One of the misconceptions is that DOT doesn't double-impact test their helmets, when in fact they do. In their testing variances, Snell uses a harder force during their testing; the likelihood of survival is minimal, after the severity of this impact. DOT testing is the only process in which there is a time restriction on how long the rider's brain is allowed to incur the g-force transferred during the wreck. The longer g-forces are transferred to the rider's brain, the more likely that rider will incur some type of head injury.

One selling point on the Shoei Multitec is the significant reduction of g-forces during testing, when compared to the Arai LE Classic. Using the same testing protocol, there were on average 42 Gs less during each impact. This g-force reduction would theoretically reduce the seriousness of injury to the rider's head during a crash.

These findings clearly support the use of a full-face modular helmet for officers. Agencies that make this move would clearly see reduced injuries during wrecks and better protect the motor officers.

Editor's note: For a more complete version of Officer Carrick's report, read the Arizona Police Science Journal's May 2011 issue starting with Page 28.

Author

Carrick Cook
Carrick Cook

Officer

Officer Carrick R. Cook is the Public Information Officer for the Arizona Department of Public Safety and a former motor officer with that agency.

View Bio

Officer Carrick R. Cook is the Public Information Officer for the Arizona Department of Public Safety and a former motor officer with that agency.

View Bio
0 Comments