Bank robberies in America's hinterlands are on the rise. In fact, on a per capita basis, towns of 10,000 to 25,000 are the most likely of any places to be hit, according to FBI statistics.
The rise in hold-ups, including violent ones, may stem from several factors, including criminals knowing that police are overwhelmed in the wake of Sept. 11. Also, repeat offenders from the late 1980s and early 1990s are now being released – and are striking again. Some areas, like Los Angeles, are seeing an increase in gangs willing to attempt the crime. Even the wobbling economy may be contributing, by creating more desperation.
At the same time, FBI Director Robert Muller has asked field offices to report to him on the feasibility of downsizing or eliminating FBI bank-robbery investigations. Some argue that FBI responsibility for carjackings and drug-enforcement should revert to local cops, too.
Observers say one likely course is to have the FBI simply support local and state agencies with crime analysis – rather than sending its agents to pound the pavement.
Any pullback, however, would mark a major change in the mythology of American crime-busting – in which the FBI has played a leading role. In the 1930s and '40s, FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover helped create a mystique for his fledgling agency as it nabbed famous bank-robbing crooks like John Dillinger and George "Machine Gun" Kelly. FBI talents include creating profiles of bank robbers and tracking the highly mobile criminals across counties and states.
Yet some observers say there has long been a gap between myth and reality, with state and local police doing much of the bank-robbery gumshoe work. "Most agencies I've talked to say they don't get all that much help out of the FBI – and yet the FBI comes in and gets most of the credit," says criminologist John Eck at the University of Cincinnati.
Recent improvements – better databases, faster communication among agencies, and sharper profiling skills – have made local and state agencies better equipped to handle bank robberies. If anything, Dr. Eck says, the impact of an FBI pullback would mostly be felt in small towns.