While I have had better, and worse, evaluations both before and since, I probably appreciated his the most because I was amazed at his ability to put aside some deserved reservations about me and document my performance accordingly. I might not have ever felt warm fuzzies about the man, but I respected him immensely for this.
Conversely, there was a peer of his who I'll just say I wasn't particularly enamored of (OK, I hated his guts). Not only was I pretty damn sure that he'd done a hit and run to my piece of shit Porsche 924 in the station parking lot, but the sawed-off li'l bastard had a Napoleonic complex that would have embarrassed Kim Jong Il.
In due time, he ended up becoming a police hazard hit in the station's jurisdiction. You know the kind: "Resident is former LEO with special weapons training who has numerous dogs and firearms at the location. Also: Crazy. Plan on bringing a sergeant and a Navy SEAL Team with you when you roll." Whatever else, the wife says I've always done a fine job of picking my enemies.
Anyway, one early Sunday morning, my radio car partner — Earl Shields, now a commander on the department — and I rolled on a heart attack victim.
L.A. County Fire got lost rolling to the location and we ended up working on the guy for fifteen minutes. I had cannily angled myself in a position to do the compressions, thereby allowing Earl the favor of the mouth-to-mouth stuff. Unfortunately, I was completely ignorant that I would be doing said compressions for fifteen minutes. By the time Fire arrived, I was drenched in sweat and exhausted (and this was when I was in shape, too … these days, I'd just end up on the floor right next to the guy).