At this point, Marshalik and Pekearo have gone above and beyond the call of duty for two unpaid auxiliary cops. After all, they have no weapons other than batons. They could have pulled back without any dishonor. But instead they split up and trailed Garvin down the street, keeping their distance but still watching his every move.
A security video reportedly captured what happened next. Garvin saw the armed cops blocking off the street ahead and turned back toward the two auxiliaries.
On the east side of Sullivan, Garvin saw Pekearo trying to take cover behind a parked car. He shot Pekearo seven times at close range. Only one of the rounds was stopped by the ballistic vest that Pekearo had purchased for himself and wore on the street.
Garvin then ran to the west side of Sullivan where he found Marshalik, also taking cover behind a car. He executed the 19-year-old aspiring officer with a single shot to the back of the head.
By this time armed officers were closing on the gunman. Garvin engaged them in a running gun battle. He was cornered in a doorway by four officers. Witnesses told the New York Times that they clearly heard the officers shout, "Police! Don't move! Drop your weapon!" But Garvin did not comply and died in a hail of bullets.