Hickey offered to buy the dog for $3,500 — Ajax's estimated value – when he retired Jan. 25. But that sale wouldn't be legal under Ohio law, and fears emerged that Ajax would be sold at auction.
Hupp said an agreement was reached Thursday that would allow Hickey to serve as an auxiliary officer and keep Ajax, and that Hickey wasn't bound by confidentiality and should have made mention of the city's efforts to the media.
"We both expressed it would be a win-win for everyone: the city, him, the department, and Ajax," said Hupp. "I regarded the matter as being resolved."
Hickey shouted from the audience that the chief was "making up small lies."
Despite the controversy, city officials will still allow Hickey the chance to serve as an auxiliary officer and keep Ajax.