Prosecutors countered that the beating was particularly vicious and not the result of impulse. "This was an intentional, methodical, purposeful, extensive beating over 15 minutes of sickening acts," Assistant U.S. Attorney Mel Johnson said.
Judge Clevert agreed with the prosecutors. "In my estimation, it would be a travesty if I were to adopt the rationale discussed for a below-guidelines sentence," he said.
The victim, Jude, was not in court. He is in jail on a probation violation. His attorney read a statement that said in part: "You violated my civil rights and you attempted to kill me. You took my life. You are a disgrace to the police uniform."
The incident not only inflamed Milwaukee's minority community, it also had an explosive effect on the Milwaukee Police Department. Chief Nannette Hegerty fired nine officers, suspended three, and demoted one all on the same day.
Seven officers, including Bartlett, Masarik, and Spengler have been convicted in the case. Two pleaded guilty and have been sentenced. Two others face sentencing next week.