Aware that the suspect was holding the hostages at knifepoint, Sheriff Scott Bradley and his deputies wanted to have the suspect surrender on his own, without having to use force. After some time, Sheriff Bradley contacted the Arkansas State Police and requested a negotiator be sent to the scene.
Just after 8 am, Corporal Blake Wilson arrived on the scene and assumed the position of lead negotiator. Wilson immediately noticed that the suspect, who was sitting in the driver's seat, had placed his daughter in his lap with her back against his chest, effectively using her as a human shield. Still worse, the suspect was holding a hunting knife against his daughter's chest, while his terrified former spouse sat beside him holding her daughter's hand. All four doors of the vehicle were locked, but the front passenger's window was partially open, allowing Wilson to speak with the suspect.
For five hours, Wilson spoke with the suspect, who became increasingly agitated with each passing hour. At approximately 1 pm, with growing concern that negotiations might not be successful, the Arkansas State Police SWAT team was activated and sent to the scene. By 2:30 pm, Sgt. Steven Bryan Davis, a SWAT member, arrived and was briefed by those already on the scene. Davis positioned himself close to Corporal Wilson in order to listen in on the negotiations. As the situation became more intense, the officers could hear the cries of the child as her father pushed the blade of the knife against her chest, causing her considerable pain.
Suddenly, at approximately 5 pm, the suspect demanded that everyone, with the exception of Corporal Wilson and several family members who had arrived on the scene, move back from the pickup truck. His paranoia heightened by the drugs he had ingested, the suspect insisted that someone was sneaking up to the truck. Corporal Wilson convinced the suspect that he could see for himself that no one else was there, if he would allow the passenger's door to be opened and have the suspect's former spouse exit the vehicle momentarily.
As the hostage exited the vehicle, Corporal Wilson removed items from the front seat and unlocked the driver's door using the pickup's electric locks on the passenger door. The ruse was successful: the suspect did not know that Sergeant Davis was on scene, nor did he realize that Corporal Davis had cleared a path and created an entry point into the vehicle.