Police Magazine Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Rules of Engagement

They wanted to know why Walters didn't shoot the knife out of Collins' hand? Shoot to maim? Why would Walters be in fear for his life since he was wearing body armor? And they wanted to know, could an X-acto knife really kill you?

Rules of Engagement

A crazed, homeless man used a razor knife similar to this one when he confronted Portland Officer Jason Walters. Photo via Flickr.com (vrogy).

4 min to read


On March 22, Officer Jason Walters of the Portland (Ore.) Police Bureau was put in a position where no police officer wants to be. His back was literally up against a wall and an apparently demented man was approaching him with an edged weapon.

Thus began a nightmare for Walters who has been second-guessed in the press, accused of murder by groups of anarchists who have marched in Portland's oh so liberal streets, and even subjected to the absurdity of police "expert" the Rev. Jesse Jackson questioning Walters' tactics.

Ad Loading...

According to grand jury testimony by Walters and others, the March 22 incident went down like this.

At 3:05 p.m. 911 dispatchers received a call from the staff at Portland's Hoyt Arboretum saying that some homeless guy was drunk, bothering the park's visitors, and had threatened one woman. There was no mention of a knife.

Officer Walters, who knew the Arboretum and the local homeless well and even thought he might know the subject by name, volunteered to take the call. He also requested the assistance of the local detox unit.

The call wasn't a very high priority for anyone because there had been no mention of a weapon or actual violence. So Walters arrived 19 minutes later at 3:24. He was told that the subject was in the restroom. Walters knocked on the door and announced his presence. He expected a drunken homeless guy to come out and figured it would be pretty easy to persuade the guy to take a ride and sleep it off.

But the man who came out of the bathroom was not just drunk and homeless. He was by all accounts: crazed. He was holding a stainless-steel handled X-acto and he apparently had used it to cut on himself while in the men's restroom. Blood streaked his face and beard. And he moved "deliberately" toward Walters holding the X-acto.

Ad Loading...

Walters ordered the man to "drop it" while he backed up and considered his options. He knew he could only back up so far because of a rock and shrub wall that blocked his retreat. He wanted to use his OC spray, but the subject was too far away. He wanted to use his TASER, but the subject had a knife and Walters had no backup to provide lethal cover. "Drop it!" Walters yelled repeatedly. He couldn't think of the word "knife," the "it" that he wanted the subject to drop. (Walters later told the grand jury that he was "more scared" by this incident than anything he has faced in 13 years of police work.)

The subject kept moving forward, X-acto in hand. Walters backed up. The wall was getting closer. Worse, if he waited much longer, he knew that the angle of any defensive shots he might fire might send his rounds into the visitors center. "Drop it!"

In fear of his life, Walters opened fire. Two rounds struck the subject, but he kept coming. Walters fired two more. The subject - later identified as 58-year-old Jack Dale Collins - went down, mortally wounded.

A grand jury cleared Walters of any wrongdoing in the shooting. But before it returned that finding, this panel asked some of the dumbest questions in the history of jurisprudence. They wanted to know the usual: Why didn't Walters shoot the knife out of Collins' hand? Why didn't Walters shoot to maim? Why didn't the first two shots knock Collins down? Why would Walters be in fear for his life since he was wearing body armor? And my favorite of all time: An X-acto is just a small blade; could that really kill you?

That last point about the size of the knife was actually one of the primary arguments used by people who commented on stories in the Portland News and a primary contention of the city's liberal elite. Only someone who has never faced the real possibility of being slashed or stabbed would ask such a question. It's stupid beyond reason.

Ad Loading...

And that fortunately is the legal standard: reason. Graham v. Connor says officers can defend themselves with deadly force if they reasonably believe they are facing imminent death or serious bodily injury. That's the rules of engagement, and the Portland protesters, the anarchists, the news media, and even the Rev. Jesse Jackson can't change them. Thank God.

Subscribe to our newsletter

More Patrol

Hands insert an Adept Armor protective plate into a camouflage tactical plate carrier, demonstrating how the armor plate fits inside the vest.
PatrolSeptember 17, 2026

Adept Armor Introduces Two New Rifle Plates

Adept Armor has launched two new Level IV ballistic plates, the Emperor and the Archon Mark 2, which brings Adept Armor’s new Quatroid ceramic to the high-threat, performance-value center of the range at 5.2 pounds.

Read More →
Open Benchmade folding knife with a bronze-colored blade, textured dark handle, and braided lanyard resting on weathered wooden boards.
Patrolby Wayne ParhamSeptember 17, 2026

POLICE Product Test: Benchmade Bailout

The Benchmade Bailout is a slim, lightweight carry knife with a deep-ride pocket clip and comes in a variety of blade steels and scales. Here is a detailed review of the Taiga Green Bailout, released earlier this year.

Read More →
Officer of the Month graphic honoring Deputy Lorne Juday of the Osceola County, Michigan, Sheriff’s Office for July 2026, featuring a portrait of Juday in uniform.
PatrolSeptember 17, 2026

NLEOMF Announces July 2026 Officer of the Month

NLEOMF honored a Michigan deputy sheriff as the July 2026 Officer of the Month for rescuing a trapped driver from a burning vehicle following a Fourth of July crash.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Streamlight promotional graphic featuring the LiteBox 1 Million handheld light and Portable Scene Light III, highlighting products displayed for the 2026 National Safety Council Safety Congress & Expo in Indianapolis, Sept. 14–16.
PatrolSeptember 10, 2026

Streamlight to Showcase Newest Lighting Products at National Safety Council’s Safety Congress & Expo 2026

Streamlight will showcase its latest lights, including the Portable Scene Light III and the LiteBox 1Million, at the 2026 National Safety Council (NSC) Safety Congress & Expo.

Read More →
Graphic promoting the 2027 World Police & Fire Games in Perth, Australia, featuring an aerial city view and photos of international participants carrying Brazilian and Australian flags.
PatrolSeptember 10, 2026

The 2027 World Police & Fire Games Set for Perth, Australia

The 2027 World Police & Fire Games (WPFG) will take place in Perth, Western Australia, from Friday, March 12 through Sunday, March 21, 2027.

Read More →
New York City skyline at night with the Tribute in Light beams illuminating the sky in remembrance of September 11, with the 5.11 logo in the upper left.
PatrolSeptember 10, 2026

5.11 Partners with National Fallen Firefighters Foundation to Support #ForThe343

5.11 has joined the nationwide movement honoring the 343 New York City Fire Department firefighters lost on Sept. 11, 2001.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Team Wendy graphic announcing sponsorship of the Jorge Pastore Foundation, featuring a black-and-white photo of Austin Police Officer Jorge Pastore, whose end of watch was November 11, 2023.
PatrolAugust 27, 2026

Team Wendy Announces Title Sponsorship of the Jorge Pastore Foundation

Team Wendy’s 3-year partnership with the Jorge Pastore Foundation expands access to programs that strengthen those who serve.

Read More →
National Law Enforcement Officers Memorial Fund graphic for the 2026 9/11 commemoration ceremony beside a close-up of a police officer’s badge, with blurred emergency lights in the background.
PatrolAugust 27, 2026

National Law Enforcement Memorial and Museum Hosting 9/11 25th-Year Commemoration Ceremony

The National Law Enforcement Memorial and Museum is hosting a 9/11 25th Year Commemoration Ceremony on Sept. 11 at 4 p.m.

Read More →
Officer of the Month graphic for June 2026 honoring officers of the Chico, California, Police Department, featuring the department’s police badge and a rose emblem.
PatrolAugust 20, 2026

National Law Enforcement Officers Memorial Fund Announces June 2026 Officers of the Month

The National Law Enforcement Officers Memorial Fund (NLEOMF) named 15 officers of the Chico Police Department (California) as the Officers of the Month for June 2026 for their roles in responding to an active-shooter incident at a public library.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Three smartphone screens display the Team Wendy community app, featuring tactical gear content, upcoming events, news, surveys, and navigation tools for warranty, sizing, and user profiles.
PatrolAugust 13, 2026

Team Wendy App Creates New Digital Hub for Helmet Owners

The Team Wendy Community App provides one location for warranty registration, size-fit tools, product updates, and community connection. For helmet owners, the new app creates a simpler path to the information and tools that matter most.

Read More →