Returning to a neighborhood is a necessity sometimes. In some neighborhoods, it's even a great tactic. Take the drug-infested street corner, several doors from where your caper occurred. The dealers are just itching for you to finish up so they can get back to business. I've seen them so eager to peddle their wares that they were in my rear view mirror, flagging down cars, just as I was turning to leave the block. So, if you have an unsolved case and you're pretty sure someone in the neighborhood knows who is responsible, go back again and again. Show up in the evening, when the dealers are real active, and park a few car lengths from them, with your blue light on the dash. Then watch the frustration on their faces as their would-be customers drive by, totally spooked.
We had a case back in the '80s where we had been told that it was the local dealers who all had the low-down on what happened and why. So we parked down the street, just as I described, and we even turned on our blue lights when we saw a deal go down. One dealer stomped off in anger, cussing us every which way, and we got a great laugh out of it. We showed up in that little enclave of the projects every day and night for a solid week. We even got out of our cars, went over to a group of the local pushers, and told them, "We're gonna be hanging around here in everyone's faces until we get some answers on that homicide." We finally got our phone call, and we closed our case.
Canvass in Person
I've heard of people going back to the office, getting out the cross-reference index, and calling the residents on the phone. This is poor police work; it is lazy police work; and it is a waste of time. If you do get anyone to answer the phone in this day and age of answering machines and cell phones, you don't know who you are really talking to and, for that matter, neither do they. You are inviting them to lie, or to evade, and you are making it easy for them to do so. The only way to effectively interview anyone is face to face, where you can use all your skills of observation and where they have nowhere to hide their reactions.
In 21 years of homicide investigation I've been involved in more area canvasses than I can remember. On one case, we went back to two neighborhoods five times, each time after learning new information. By that time, we knew when the ice cream truck and private school vans were arriving, and we interviewed their drivers too. We went to the suspects' workplaces, too, and canvassed the office building there to find out more.