Police Magazine Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Editorial: Lions and Tigers and Bears

The sheriff of Muskingum County, Ohio, Matt Lutz, and his officers went to work on Oct. 19, probably expecting the usual routine operations of a rural sheriff's department. But before the day was over they became reluctant big game hunters.

November 7, 2011
Editorial: Lions and Tigers and Bears

Photo: Danny Nicholson.

4 min to read


Terry Thompson, owner of Muskingum County Animal Farm, reportedly opened all the gates to the cages of his exotic menagerie then shot himself in the head. And suddenly the sheriff of Muskingum County, Ohio, Matt Lutz, was presented with a tactical problem that has never faced any American law enforcement official: There were numerous large, exotic predatory animals roaming his jurisdiction.

Lutz and his officers went to work on Oct. 19, probably expecting the usual routine operations of a rural sheriff's department. But before the day was over they became reluctant big game hunters.

Ad Loading...

There's a lesson in that for all American law enforcement officers. But before I get to it, I'd like to give you a slice of what Lutz and his deputies actually dealt with during this incident.

Lutz told reporters that the first deputies called to the scene were confronted by a tiger. Their reaction was to open fire on the cat with their sidearms. Anybody who hunts large animals can tell you that a .40 caliber pistol is a bad weapons choice for the job. So imagine the abject terror of a cop facing down a tiger with a pistol. That officer is not trained for such a contingency.

After that initial encounter, Lutz and his deputies started to approach the problem with much more tactical precision. Their first priority was to prevent the assortment of lions, tigers, leopards, and bears from attacking the local population. Few Americans are aware of this fact, but tigers, lions, and bears still eat people in this world.

Lutz and his deputies warned the public to stay inside. Schools were closed for the following day in the surrounding area. Lutz told the press that he didn't want kids waiting on school buses to encounter any of the escaped predators.

Then the officers started to work the problem. One issue they faced was they weren't sure how many animals and what types of animals had escaped. So they rounded up people who had worked on the farm and compiled inventories. Final count was 56, including 18 adult Bengal tigers.

Ad Loading...

Knowing what they were up against, the officers started to gather resources. They assembled night vision equipment and rifles, and they called in experts from the nearby Columbus Zoo, including retired zookeeper and media personality Jack Hanna. Sheriff Lutz made it clear to his officers from the beginning that he wanted the animals killed if they represented any threat to the public. So the officers of the Muskingum County Sheriff's Department fanned out and went hunting.

Many people have questioned Lutz's decision to put down the exotic creatures, including some endangered species. They've asked why the animals couldn't be shot with tranquilizers. There are many reasons why this wouldn't have worked, but most people asking this question have no concept of how difficult it would be for any American law enforcement agency to assemble enough tranquilizer guns and vets to perform such operations. An attempt actually was made to "trank" a tiger. It failed when the animal bolted after it was hit with the dart. Officers were forced to kill it.

Lutz and his officers did exactly what any law enforcement officer is supposed to do when confronted by a threat: They protected the public that they serve. Lutz was decisive in his command decision to kill the animals. And he's taking heat for it. But even the People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) said the blame for the tragedy was not on the officers but on lax laws that allow people like Thompson to collect live exotic animals. Hanna says the officers did the right thing and added that the incident was like "Noah's Ark wrecking in eastern Ohio."

OK. Here's the lesson for all law enforcement officers that should be learned from this incident: Anything that can happen will. Be aware of what is in your jurisdiction. If there's a chemical plant, be prepared for an airborne toxic release. If there's a dam, be prepared for a flood. If there's a farm that houses lions, tigers, and velociraptors, be prepared for them to escape. Know what's in your jurisdiction and think about how to respond if the worst happens.

Finally, some of you may see this as a contradiction to the last statement, but you can't prepare for everything. Life is unpredictable. So when the unthinkable does happen, respond quickly, act decisively, and be prepared to take the heat. The people you serve deserve nothing less.

Subscribe to our newsletter

More Patrol

Black small medical bag with supplies and a tourniquet at right on a wood table and a large headline at left What Should Be In Your IFAK?
Patrolby Wayne ParhamMay 1, 2026

What Should Be in Your IFAK?

What should every officer include in an IFAK? Sydney Vail, M.D., a veteran trauma surgeon and former SWAT surgeon, explains which components are needed and which are not, and stresses training.

Read More →
flashlight turn un and submerged in puddle with rain falling.
PatrolApril 30, 2026

Olight Releases 2 New Baton Variants & the ArkPro Ultra Onyx Black

Olight has added two new lights to the Baton Series, the Baton 4 and the Baton Ultra. One new Baton features up to 1,600 lumens on turbo, and the other 1,800.

Read More →
Black tactical helmet with bright explosion behind it to the left, Team Wendy logo top right, and headline Recon Tactical Bump Helmet
PatrolApril 30, 2026

Team Wendy Reveals New RECON Tactical Bump Helmet

Team Wendy’s new RECON Tactical bump helmet is configurable by color, retention, and accessories for rescue, tactical, and military mission needs. It features Zorbium foam pads, shell vents, and lattice cooling pads that balance impact absorption, airflow, and long-wear support.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Black military style leather boot against a blue cobblestone background with a white Garmont Tactical logo.
PatrolApril 30, 2026

Garmont Tactical Introduces the T8 Specter LE Zip for LE Professionals

Garmont Tactical has a new 8-inch duty boot with a side zipper, the T8 Specter LE Zip. The boot is available now and features ankle support in a standard duty profile with polishable leather.

Read More →
Streamlight searchlight and a scene light on a tripod set against a darkened street scene and Streamlight logo across the top.
PatrolApril 30, 2026

Streamlight Launches LiteBox 1Million & Portable Scene Light III

Streamlight has launched the Portable Scene Light III (PSL III), which delivers up to 10,000 lumens, and the LiteBox 1Million, a one-million-candela long-range search light.

Read More →
Two camo magazine puches against a blue tinted police background and a logo for Tasmanian Tiger.
PatrolApril 22, 2026

Tasmanian Tiger Introduces the TT SGL Mag Pouch Clamp M4

Tasmanian Tiger has launched the TT SGL Mag Pouch Clamp M4, an open magazine pouch engineered for M4/AR-15 platforms that integrates a plastic clamping device for secure retention and fast magazine deployment.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Police officer in a darkened hallway holding a flashlight and headline 5 Things to Know When Buying Patrol Lights, and POLICE logo.
PatrolApril 16, 2026

5 Things to Know When Buying Patrol Lights

Whether it’s time to buy a personal patrol light or make the decision for the next department-issued patrol light, what do you need to know? How do you weigh the different variables and make the best choice?

Read More →
Group of men and women seated in a circle around a room as one woman stands and leads discussion.
PatrolApril 9, 2026

Warriors Heart’s Mission to Serve America’s Veterans and First Responders

Warriors Heart works closely with federal and community partners to expand treatment options for veterans and first responders. By combining specialized clinical care with a peer-driven recovery environment, the program helps warriors rebuild strength, restore relationships, and rediscover purpose.

Read More →
Black background with police card lights and logo for POLICE, with headline in yellow: How are LE Boots Different for Women
Patrolby Wayne ParhamApril 9, 2026

How are LE Boots Different for Women?

Boots fit differently for men and women, so how are law enforcement boots for women designed differently from those worn by men? In this video, Kyle Ferdyn, of Garmont Tactical, shares all the details.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Man standing in desert talking on radio.
PatrolApril 9, 2026

Motorola Solutions Extends Resilient, Mission-Critical Communications and AI with T-Satellite from T-Mobile

A collaboration between Motorola Solutions and T-Mobile helps deliver uninterrupted situational awareness and access to AI wherever the mission leads, enabled by satellite connectivity for Motorola Solutions' APX NEXT smart radios.

Read More →