Police Magazine Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Dave Smith: Stop Spreading “Civil War Porn”

It would seem leaders would desperately seek to heal the rifts, reinforce our faith in our systems of government, and tone down the rhetoric

October 14, 2022
Dave Smith: Stop Spreading  “Civil War Porn”

 

4 min to read


You don’t have to search very long or hard to find a current article or video warning about an upcoming civil crisis—a civil war—in America. On the right and on the left, both sides seem either concerned about or even anticipatory of, such a terrible event. Civil wars are bloody. America’s true “civil war,” killed over 600,000 soldiers on both sides and thousands of civilians.

The reverberations of that tragedy still resonate today, but it seems the lessons learned from this period of horrific trauma are almost forgotten. Name calling, demonization, polarization, and perception of persecution all create an atmosphere that any informed observer would say was a precursor to violence; violence that would make law enforcement not only a key player, but also a key target in any actual physical conflict that would occur.

Ad Loading...

Ted Robert Gurr was a student of political and social violence, and his groundbreaking book, “Why Men Rebel,” has been studied and analyzed since its original publication in 1970; it leads the way in helping us understanding the actual causes of political violence. His “The History of Violence in America” clearly illustrated that American society was certainly violent to some degree, experiencing political riots and discord, but an actual rebellion was extremely rare compared to the experience of the rest of the world.

“Democracy is the answer,” you might shout out in response to our relatively low number of revolts, and to a certain extent that would be true. But Gurr’s point, made over and over again, is that as long as the people believe the government is legitimate and that they have the power to change things through an election, violence will be short-circuited.

But is this the state of affairs today?

Starting in the election of 2000, and accelerating rapidly, an open disdain for the results of election and denial of the legitimacy of the winning regime, has become rampant. Both sides have claimed this, but with the amplified rhetoric since January 6 we find national tension growing exponentially. Instead of tamping down the agitation, key players have chosen to adopt open verbal warfare. Now, in my view, one’s political bent is not the issue here; my concern is the peace of our country, the preservation of our freedoms, and law enforcement’s successful completion of the difficult task ahead. The latter is in grave peril; ambushes, resisting arrest, absurd prosecutions, lack of critical prosecutions, increased retirements, lack of recruits, lack of funding, and a hostile media have created a crisis for law enforcement like nothing I have seen in my lifetime.

It would seem leaders would desperately seek to heal the rifts, reinforce our faith in our systems of government, and tone down the rhetoric; but instead we see a plethora of what the great historian Victor Davis Hanson has termed, “Civil War Porn.” Indeed, we see it all around us: mainstream media demonizes large portions of the population; billionaire internet oligarchs brag about controlling an election with money and information manipulation; and politicians and pundits make outlandish but unopposed accusations of fascism and terrorism toward “the other side,” all designed to aggravate instead of ameliorate the conflict.

Ad Loading...

Both sides talk of secession, and vocal dissatisfaction with the electoral process is becoming more and more widespread. And therein lies the root of potential violence. Gurr believed rebellions occur when people perceive their ability to change their condition has been denied and when they perceive that their ability to attain what they want is limited or gone.

America’s ability to literally change our government every two years has been the “pressure release valve” for our political frustration. The election of Lincoln signaled to the South that they could no longer win through national elections, so they sought secession and started a civil war. Our politicians need to shore up the legitimacy of our elections as soon as possible and reinforce the very things the Founders established to eliminate the possibility of revolt. Pure democracy always created a tyranny of the majority, so we have a representative form of government for which the sanctity and credibility of the franchise, the vote, is essential. The demonization of constituencies (the voters) is as toxic as anything I have seen in my lifetime, and it is imperative that we mute the tone of this political discourse. E Pluribus Unum, “from many one,” must remind us to work together in spite of our differences and seek compromise.

 I write this hoping our law enforcement leaders will sound the alarm to the politicians, admonishing them to unify instead of divide, encourage civil discourse and cooperation, and lower our nation’s temperature.

I say all this hoping the country remembers our bloody lessons learned, and avoids any more civil wars.

Subscribe to our newsletter

More Patrol

Police drone hovering over its charging nest against a blue sky background.
PatrolMarch 26, 2026

Brinc Unveils Guardian, Launching the Next Era of Drone as First Responder

Brinc’s new Guardian delivers 24/7 operations, Starlink connectivity, and a robotic charging nest that can swap batteries and change payload configurations without human intervention.

Read More →
image of trooper, shown from waist down, standing beside a police cruiser along the road and at right a headline Slow Down Move Over.
PatrolMarch 19, 2026

Colorado State Patrol Releases 2025 Struck-By Analysis

The Colorado State Patrol, after analyzing its 2025 struck-by incidents, identified one area for improvement: using traffic cones to provide advanced warning before the cruiser's location. Here is the agency’s final data.

Read More →
Image of a group of men in business attire receiving an award set against a black background and a Streamlight logo up top.
PatrolMarch 19, 2026

Streamlight Names 144th Marketing Group Law Enforcement Sales Rep Agency of the Year

Streamlight has recognized the 144th Marketing Group as its 2025 Sales Rep Agency of the Year Award for the Law Enforcement market.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Image of a group of men in business attire receiving an award set against a black background and a Streamlight logo up top.
PatrolMarch 19, 2026

Streamlight Names 144th Marketing Group Law Enforcement Sales Rep Agency of the Year

Streamlight has recognized the 144th Marketing Group as its 2025 Sales Rep Agency of the Year Award for the Law Enforcement market.

Read More →
DArk backgroundn with inset images of a fallen police officer and a ballistic helmet and headline Rife-Rated.
PatrolMarch 19, 2026

The Mission After the Moment

The mission of the Jorge Pastore Foundation is to support first responders through essential training, stronger community engagement, and mental wellness resources, all accessible and funded through donations, sponsorships, and foundation-led fundraising. It works closely with Team Wendy in the discussions about developing better protective gear for officers.

Read More →
Promotional graphic for Patrolfinder featuring a police chief’s headshot inside a circular frame alongside a police SUV in the background. The headline reads: “Built for Patrol: How One Police Chief Fixed Communication, Boosted Visibility, and Changed the Culture.”
SponsoredMarch 17, 2026

Built for Patrol: How One Police Chief Fixed Communication, Boosted Visibility, and Changed the Culture

Patrol work hasn’t changed—but the expectations on officers have. See how one police chief helped officers get the right information at the right time, improve patrol visibility, and strengthen trust without adding complexity or surveillance. This real-world story shows how patrol-driven technology can make the job safer, smarter, and more effective—starting on day one.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Man in a blue blazer lifting his shirt to reveal a concealed handgun in a waistband holster while standing outdoors.
SponsoredMarch 2, 2026

Safariland Solis Rethinks Concealable Duty

What if Level I retention didn’t require a full duty rig? Safariland’s Solis delivers trusted ALS security in a streamlined OWB platform built for administrative and plainclothes professionals who need protection without the bulk.

Read More →
Woman kneeling with a Bloodhound in front of a white pickup truck.
PatrolMarch 1, 2026

K-9s Play a Critical Role in Finding Missing Persons

Real-world scenarios show that a tracking canine can detect and follow a human track several hours after it was made.

Read More →
Black background with image of police car light bar, logo for POLICE Topics, Tactics & Tips, and headline What are the latest law enforcement boots from Garmont Tactical?
Patrolby Wayne ParhamFebruary 25, 2026

Garmont Tactical’s LE Boot Lineup

In this video, we get a look at the latest law enforcement boots from Garmont Tactical, both for men and women. Kyle Ferdyn, sales manager, showcases four of the latest boots.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Person in protective CMRN suit and breathing gear.
PatrolFebruary 18, 2026

Avon Protection Launches EXOSKIN-S2 High-Performance CBRN Protective Suit

With the commercial availability of Avon Protection’s EXOSKIN-S2, users now have increased options for their protective suit requirements across the spectrum of CBRN threat environments.

Read More →