POLICE Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Americans Chime in on Prison Alternatives

A nationwide survey conducted by the Pew Center on the States, Public Opinion Strategies and the Mellman Group recently queried Americans about their thoughts on incarceration of both violent and non-violent criminals, alternative rehabilitation strategies, and the effort to reduce the nation’s expenditure on traditional prisons.

by Staff
August 14, 2013
Americans Chime in on Prison Alternatives

Photo courtesy of Regis University

Content provided by Regis University

Pew research shows support for reduced sentences and alternative corrections is broad.

Ad Loading...

 

A nationwide survey conducted by the Pew Center on the States, Public Opinion Strategies and the Mellman Group recently queried Americans about their thoughts on incarceration of both violent and non-violent criminals, alternative rehabilitation strategies, and the effort to reduce the nation's expenditure on traditional prisons.

Overall, support for a reduction in the prison population was strong (though not equal) though dissimilar results across political and geographic lines. More than 45% of those polled say there are currently too many people behind bars in the U.S. Only 13% believe there are too few, while 28% said the size of the prison population was "about right." When asked how many prisoners could be hypothetically released without posing a threat to public safety, the average response was 20%.

Researchers than gauged respondents' reactions to this: "Some of the money that we are spending on locking up low-risk, non-violent inmates should be shifted to strengthening community corrections programs like probation and parole." Nationwide, 84% of those polled either strongly or totally agreed with the idea, though reactions were more mixed when responses were broken down by political affiliation. More than 91% of Democrats either strongly or totally agreed compared with 85% of Independents and 77% of Republicans. Support for a shift away from non-violent criminal incarceration was also stronger in the Northeast and West regions of the country, with softer support in the South and Midwest.

Interestingly, the concept of shortening an inmate's prison sentence, but then requiring a mandatory period of supervision after release was supported equally by those polled—even when the idea was applied to both violent and non-violent offenders. If a non-violent offender was sentenced to five years in prison, 69% of survey respondents thought it would be better to release the offender after four years followed by a full year of supervision. For violent convicts, 67% still thought early release was a good idea, provided there was proper supervision after the criminal was released into society.

Use of new tracking technology was strongly supported by nearly all Americans represented in the survey to help strengthen the effectiveness of probation, parole and supervision programs. More than 92% of those polled either totally or strongly agreed with the concept of using new electronic tools to monitor where offenders are and what they are doing—whether that supervision occurs after, or as an alternative to, incarceration. The same percentage favored the requirement that offenders under supervision pass drug tests and either keep a job or perform community service while being supervised.

Overall, respondents rated the safety of their own communities relatively high, a factor that promotes open-mindedness about prison reform. On average, survey respondents said the level of safety in their local neighborhoods was about 8 out of 10-point scale, with 10 representing the safest.

 

Source: " Public Opinion on Sentencing and Corrections Policy in America "

The survey included responses from 1,200 likely voters, 32% identifying themselves as Republicans, 24% as Independents and 37% as Democrats. The margin of error in the poll is plus or minus 2.8%.

To learn more, explore Regis University’s Master’s of Science in Criminology degree program .


Ad Loading...
Subscribe to our newsletter

More Training

patrolfinder - reducing crime thumbnail
SponsoredOctober 27, 2025

How One Police Department Cut Crime by 46% with Smarter Patrol Management

Discover how one police department cut crime nearly in half using smarter patrol data. This whitepaper breaks down the real-world strategy behind a 46% drop in vehicle thefts, improved officer safety, and stronger community visibility.

Read More →
Thumbnail for video series POLICE Topics, Tactics & Tips with a yellow headline that reads When Do You Transport a Wounded Officer Instead of Waiting for EMS?
Patrolby Wayne ParhamOctober 26, 2025

When Do You Transport a Wounded Officer Instead of Waiting for EMS?

Thumbnail for video series POLICE Topics, Tactics & Tips with a yellow headline that reads When Do You Transport a Wounded Officer Instead of Waiting for EMS?

Read More →
Safariland header photo
Sponsoredby David ReederOctober 22, 2025

Is Your Duty Holster Duty Rated?

The first – and worst – time I had to fight to keep my gun, my holster and duty belt held up far better than my training did.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Flock Safety Webinar Banner
SponsoredOctober 7, 2025

Beyond the Plate: Real-Time Video Intelligence for Police Operations

Join us for an inside look at how agencies are enhancing frontline decision-making with visual intelligence that goes beyond the plate. This session will show how pairing LPR data with live camera feeds delivers faster, safer, and more coordinated responses—on everything from stolen vehicles to active BOLOs.

Read More →
Coffee Break With Police Experts thumnail for topic of Using Your Patrol Vehicle for Cover.
Sponsoredby Wayne ParhamOctober 3, 2025

Coffee Break with Police Experts: Using Your Patrol Vehicle for Cover

In this video, hear from Dustin Mowery, a product specialist at Team Wendy, as he discusses how to best use a patrol vehicle for cover.

Read More →
Two police officers in tactical vests, demonstrating emerging law enforcement technology
SponsoredSeptember 1, 2025

Ebook: How Data-Driven Policing Strengthens Transparency and Public Trust

Whether your department is focused on improving transparency or rebuilding community confidence, this ebook offers real examples and practical strategies to help. Learn how data-driven insights and modern fleet technologies can strengthen accountability, support officer safety, and enhance public trust.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Police officer crouching behind vehicle, holding rifle in tactical stance
Vehicle Opsby Wayne ParhamAugust 29, 2025

Using Patrol Vehicles for Cover

While a patrol vehicle offers some cover protection when taking fire, remain mobile and don’t stick to one piece of cover indefinitely. Dustin Mowery, of Team Wendy, shares what he teaches about using vehicles as cover.

Read More →
TrainingAugust 25, 2025

San Francisco Police Recruit Dies in Training

Recruit Officer Jon-Marques Psalms, 30, reportedly suffered a medical emergency after completing a training exercise on Wednesday August 20, 2025, at the Academy.

Read More →
TechnologyAugust 25, 2025

POLICE and Flock Safety Present Webinar on Combining LPR with Real-Time Video

The webinar titled “Beyond the Plate: Real-Time Video Intelligence for Police Operations” will show how pairing LPR data with live camera feeds delivers faster, safer, and more coordinated responses on everything from stolen vehicles to active BOLOs.

Read More →
Ad Loading...