POLICE Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

The Plight of the "Pit Bull"

“My heart goes out to these dogs,” says trainer Brian Kilcommons, who is often called to assess the aggressiveness and socialization of pits. “These dogs are so maligned. They are tortured. They are fought. I cannot tell you how many of these dogs I have trained that make phenomenal pets.”

November 4, 2014
The Plight of the "Pit Bull"

Just because a dog looks like a pit bull does not mean it is "vicious" or even "aggressive. You can only judge the animal as a threat by its actions. (Photo: National Canine Research Council)

Most shootings of pet dogs by law enforcement officers involve large and medium breed dogs that are considered “dangerous,” including Rottweilers, German shepherds, and pit bulls. But it’s important for officers to know that a shooting can’t be justified just by the perceived breed of the dog.

Dogs referred to as pit bulls are particularly prone to being shot by officers. And many dog behavior experts believe this is because of the breed’s bad press. It is often true that the only dog breed specifically named in stories about dog bites is the "pit bull."

Ad Loading...

The “pit bull” was originally bred in England by mating mastiffs with terriers. The goal of the breeders was to create a dog with the power of a mastiff and the never-quit spirit of a terrier that could be used for sport such as bear baiting and bull baiting and dog fighting. Contrary to popular belief the dog was not bred to attack humans, in fact that would be the last thing that the dog handlers working in the ring during dog fights would want.

Today, pit bulls are still used for sport, but they are more likely to be family pets and protection animals ( sometimes by bad guys who use them as weapons ) Pit mixes are now some of the most common dogs in America. The pit and pit mix population is now so hight in this country that Esquire magazine recently called them "The American Dog."

Unfortunately, the American dog is not very well loved. Each day thousands of them are destroyed in shelters nationwide because their ownership is outlawed in that community, because people are afraid of adopting them, because apartments and homeowner associations ban them, and/or because some insurance companies won't write home policies for people who own them.

Dog trainers and dog behaviorists will tell you that despite their fearsome reputation and the dog bite statistics  that are often used to damn them, the vast majority of pit bulls are no more dangerous than any other large pet dog.

“My heart goes out to these dogs,” says trainer Brian Kilcommons , who has worked with 40,000 dogs and who is often called to assess the aggressiveness and socialization of pits. “These dogs are so maligned. They are tortured. They are fought. I cannot tell you how many of these dogs I have trained that make phenomenal pets.”

Ad Loading...

Kilcommons also warns officers that making an assumption that a dog is vicious because it is a pit bull can lead the people around the dog, including the officer, to be afraid, which can elicit an aggressive response from the dog. “Once you start working off of fear, the signals you are giving that dog are very confusing,” he says.

Another problem that officers often have when encountering dogs that appear to be pit bulls is that they put that description in their reports. And that's a big mistake because even dog experts can have difficulty judging the breed of an animal without a DNA test. Calling a dog a "pit" in your report when it isn't one can lead to a smart lawyer challenging you in court over that identification.

“They’ve got to stop calling every dog a ‘pit bull,’” says Jim Osorio, lead trainer for police training company Canine Encounters . Osorio tells the story of a trainer who used to put 100 photos of dogs on a chart and ask people to identify which ones were pit bulls. The vast majority of people identified most of the dogs as pits. Only two were actually purebred “pit bulls.”

Osorio also points out that several different breeds are included in the “pit bull” classification, including the American Pitbull Terrier, the American Staffordshire Terrier, and the Staffordshire Bull Terrier. “Pit bull is a nickname,” he says.

And even if you can identify a pit bull by sight, just because a dog is a pit or pit mix does not mean it necessarily will be aggressive or more aggressive than any other dog in the same circumstance.

Ad Loading...

“There’s an overemphasis on the viciousness of particular dog breed,” says Cynthia Bathurst, founder of Safe Humane Chicago. She adds that determining the behavior of a dog by its physical appearance is a losing game, “One-quarter of one percent of a dog’s DNA determines what a dog’s head looks like.”

Kilcommons cautions officers not to believe the media hype about certain dog breeds. “Generalizations don’t work. It’s not the breed; it’s the deed,” he explains.

Ad Loading...
Subscribe to our newsletter

More Patrol

black background width image of police lights in middle and headline Dashcam Video Officers rescue Man from Burning Car
PatrolNovember 17, 2025

Dashcam Video Shows Officers Rescue Man from Burning Car

Dashcam video released by a New Jersey police department shows two of its officers rescuing an unconscious man from a burning car after a crash.

Read More →
blue background with image of a red dot sight and also second image of the red dot on a handgun lower right
PatrolNovember 17, 2025

Aimpoint COA optic + A-CUT Named Red Dot of the Year

The Aimpoint COA optic + A-CUT system has been named Red Dot of the Year by Guns & Ammo magazine. The new optic system was introduced in January 2025.

Read More →
Thumbnail for video series POLICE From the Show Floor, with headline text featuring Axon
Patrolby Wayne ParhamNovember 16, 2025

From the Show Floor: Axon

Join POLICE as we visit with Abi Stock, of Axon, to learn about the company’s latest technology offerings, such as Axon Assistant, Form One, and the DFR integration with Skydio.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
side view of a ballistic helmet in studio setting, black background, with sparks and smoke
PatrolNovember 16, 2025

Back Face Deformation, Brain Injury and Ballistic Helmets – Why the “Dent Doesn’t Matter” Claim Ignores Science

Alex Poythress, co-founder and CEO of Ballistic Armor Co., explains why ballistic helmet buyers should insist on full test data, including BFD measurements, standoff distance, and padding configuration, rather than rely solely on penetration ratings.

Read More →
Pink Streamlight Wedge XT flashlight.
PatrolNovember 13, 2025

Streamlight Marks 15 Years of Support for Breast Cancer Research Foundation With $20k Donation

In its 15th year of supporting the Breast Cancer Research Foundation, Streamlight donated $20,000 to help in the fight against cancer. Donations were generated through the sale of special Wedge XT models and other pink flashlights.

Read More →
center circle image of PTSD Help Expanded surrounded by military and first responder images
PatrolNovember 11, 2025

Police-Led Mental Health Charity Expands to Include Veterans

Talk To Me Post Tour (TTMPT), a non-profit organization that has been providing peer-support programs and professional psychological support for first responders, is now expanding services to military veterans.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
police officer holding a folded flag and headline for Officer Killed
PatrolNovember 10, 2025

WakeMed Campus Police Officer Killed in Hospital Shooting

A WakeMed Campus Police Officer died after being shot in the lobby of the emergency department at a North Carolina hospital over the weekend.

Read More →
Black background with blue graphic outline of state of Florida and headline Video Released: barricaded Suspect Falls Through Ceiling and Into SWAT Custody.
PatrolNovember 10, 2025

Video Shows Barricaded Suspect Fall Through Ceiling and Into SWAT Custody

Deputies in Indian River County, Florida, apprehended a suspect after he fell through the ceiling with SWAT members waiting below. The sheriff’s department released video of the apprehension.

Read More →
thumbnail for video series POLICE From the Show Floor featuring T2 Systems.
Patrolby Wayne ParhamNovember 10, 2025

From the Show Floor: T2 Systems

Learn about T2 Systems and its electronic parking enforcement solutions. Retired Chief John Holland outlines the benefits of using such a system to manage parking enforcement.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
view of a mobile observation trailer deployed in a parking lot against a blue sky
Patrolby Wayne ParhamNovember 10, 2025

Texas Police Department Adds Reconview Tower

A Texas police chief shares how the Decatur Police Department will use its new Reconview observation tower.

Read More →