On Sept. 4, 2005, Hills was one of several officers who rode in a large Budget rental truck to the Danziger Bridge, where officers engaged in two shooting incidents that left two civilians dead and four others seriously injured.
According to court documents, officers first arrived on the east side of the bridge, where they fired at the group of civilians who were walking to a supermarket to get food and supplies. One of the civilians was killed, and four members of a family were severely wounded.
Officers then traveled to the west side of the bridge, where they encountered Lance and Ronald Madison, who were crossing the bridge on their way to the dentistry office of one of their other brothers. An officer shot and killed Ronald Madison, a 40-year-old man with severe mental and physical disabilities. Officers then arrested Lance Madison and charged him with eight counts of attempted murder of a police officer.
Hills admitted that he signed a sworn statement justifying Lance Madison's arrest, even though he had no first-hand information about any wrongdoing by Madison, and even though he had concerns that Madison was being framed. Hills also admitted that he conspired with other officers and supervisors to give false statements about the shooting.
During the investigation of this incident, Hills reported that he fired his handgun at a suspect who reached for a shiny object in his waistband. Hills admitted that his initial claim was not true, and that he actually shot at a fleeing juvenile who did not reach for anything in his waistband or make any aggressive movements. Hills also admitted that he did not yell any commands or warnings, or hear any other officer do so, before he shot at the juvenile.