A fierce two minute gun battle ensued, with 80 rounds fired, resulting in a second trooper shot in the arm, and the first trooper killing the suspect with a bullet to the temple. Almost simultaneously, the first trooper was struck by a bullet to his head. The fatal round was shot by the trooper behind him.
MRT evacuated their wounded teammate and, not knowing the suspect was down, threw a tear gas canister into the house. They followed with a second canister, not realizing it was incendiary, which resulted in a fire that destroyed the house.
In the aftermath, the District Attorney determined there was no criminality, and the NY State Police Superintendent called it a "tragic accident in a very intense firefight." The trooper who fired the round that killed his teammate resigned from MRT, but remains a member of the State Police.
In the fourteen months prior to this incident, six New York troopers were killed in the line of duty, including two troopers killed by a fugitive during a massive manhunt outside Buffalo.
Ironically, the Buffalo incident also involved the MRT trooper who was killed in the farmhouse shootout.