Police Magazine Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Preserving and Disclosing Evidence

Most law enforcement officers are familiar with the term “Brady error.” But what exactly does the Brady rule cover, and what obligation does it impose on police? Under the Brady line of cases, when must officers preserve evidence, and what must be revealed to the prosecutor? These questions have been answered in a series of opinions from the U.S. Supreme Court.

December 1, 2006
6 min to read


Most law enforcement officers are familiar with the term "Brady error." But what exactly does the Brady rule cover, and what obligation does it impose on police? Under the Brady line of cases, when must officers preserve evidence, and what must be revealed to the prosecutor? These questions have been answered in a series of opinions from the U.S. Supreme Court.

The Due Process Duty to Disclose

Ad Loading...

The Fifth Amendment due process clause applies to federal officers and prosecutions; the Fourteenth Amendment due process clause applies to state and local officers and prosecutions. Both clauses guarantee fairness in the procedures used to convict a criminal defendant and to impose punishment that deprives the defendant of life (death penalty), liberty (incarceration), or property (fines).

In Napue v. Illinois, the Supreme Court considered the unfairness of a trial in which the prosecutor failed to disclose to the defense that a key prosecution witness had been promised consideration for his testimony against the defendant-a fact that could have been used by the defense to attack the witness's credibility. The court ruled that the prosecutor had a duty under the due process clause to reveal this information.

Napue was followed by Brady v. Maryland, in which the prosecutor withheld a codefendant's confession from the defendant's attorney, who had filed a discovery request for all statements made by the codefendant. The court said, "We hold that the suppression by the prosecution of evidence favorable to the accused upon request violates due process where the evidence is material either to guilt or to punishment, irrespective of the good faith or bad faith of the prosecution."

This "Brady rule" has since been applied in innumerable cases throughout the country, causing the reversal of convictions when it is shown that evidence that should have been disclosed to the defense before trial was withheld, whether inadvertently or deliberately.

In Brady, the defense attorney had made a specific request for discovery that encompassed the material withheld. But the court went further in U.S. v. Agurs and held that "there are situations in which evidence is obviously of such substantial value to the defense that elementary fairness requires it to be disclosed even without a specific request."

Ad Loading...

And in Kyles v. Whitley, the court ruled that due process is violated when Brady material is not disclosed, even though police might not have revealed the existence of the evidence to the prosecutor: "The individual prosecutor has a duty to learn of any favorable evidence known to the others acting on the government's behalf in the case, including the police."

In addition to evidence that tends to raise doubts about the defendant's guilt or that might reduce his culpability and mitigate punishment, Brady also requires disclosure of evidence that could be used to impeach prosecution witnesses (U.S. v. Bagley), including details of any inducements given in exchange for testimony. (Giglio v. U.S.) In some cases, the identities of undercover informants whose testimony might be critical to the defense may have to be disclosed. (Roviaro v. U.S.)

Police can assist the prosecutor in meeting the due process responsibility by making a full and complete accounting to the prosecutor of all known evidence in the case. Officers must inform the prosecutor of any testimonial inducements, any sustained misconduct that might tend to impeach a material police witness, the failure of an eyewitness to make an ID, etc. In short, the prosecutor must be given the good, the bad, and the ugly details of the criminal investigation, so that he or she can assess the duty to make timely disclosure and avoid "Brady error."

The Due Process Duty to Preserve

Obviously, evidence that has not been preserved by police cannot be disclosed to the prosecutor, or by the prosecutor to the defense. In some instances, police failure to keep evidence for trial may cause due process problems.

Ad Loading...

The responsibility for determining what to disclose and what to withhold is on the individual prosecutor, and "the prudent prosecutor will resolve doubtful cases in favor of disclosure." (U.S. v. Agurs) To meet the due process duty, the prosecutor must have knowledge of evidence, and the evidence must still be in existence.

The decision by police officers to include particular information in a report or to make sure that physical evidence is preserved depends on their recognizing the potentially exculpatory nature of the evidence, and having some way to preserve it. This will not always be easy, but like the prosecutor, the prudent officer will resolve doubtful cases in favor of inclusion and retention, whenever possible.

The Supreme Court first considered an issue of failure to preserve in Killian v. U.S. FBI agents had made rough notes of their interviews with an undercover operative, and after incorporating the contents of the notes into finished reports, they destroyed the notes, as was their standard practice. The defendant argued that police failure to preserve the notes deprived him of due process.

The Supreme Court rejected this argument, ruling that since the contents of the notes were reflected in the official reports to which the defense had access, there was no prejudice to the defense. "If the notes were destroyed by the agents in good faith and in accord with their normal practice, their destruction did not constitute an impermissible destruction of evidence nor deprive defendant of any right."

The court next addressed a preservation issue in California v. Trombetta, in which the DUI defendant argued that police should have preserved an ampoule of his breath for independent analysis of blood-alcohol content. Although the California courts agreed with this assertion, the U.S. Supreme Court reversed and held that due process was not violated.

Ad Loading...

To require officers to preserve an item of evidence, said the court, "the evidence must both possess an exculpatory value that was apparent before the evidence was destroyed, and be of such a nature that the defendant would be unable to obtain comparable evidence by other reasonably available means." Because it was highly unlikely a separate breath sample would have yielded a different result, there was no apparent exculpatory value in preserving a breath sample.

In Arizona v. Youngblood, the Supreme Court reversed a state ruling that a child molester had been denied due process when officers failed to preserve semen samples from the victim's clothing. The court said, "Unless a criminal defendant can show bad faith on the part of the police, failure to preserve potentially useful evidence does not constitute a denial of due process."

Bad faith would require that police realize that the evidence they were about to destroy might be exculpatory, as in Youngblood v. West Virginia (different Youngblood), where an officer allegedly told a witness to destroy her note indicating that a charged forcible sex act was in fact consensual. Such evidentiary destruction would violate due process.

Preventing Brady Error

Police have a duty to keep evidence for possible defense use if the evidence reasonably appears to have potential exculpatory value to the defendant. Both incriminating and exonerating evidence must be reported, so the prosecutor can determine what must be disclosed to the defense. Discovery statutes may impose additional disclosure requirements on police and prosecutors, and these must also be observed.

Ad Loading...

Devallis Rutledge, a former police officer and veteran prosecutor, is Special Counsel to the Los Angeles County District Attorney.

Subscribe to our newsletter

More Patrol

POLICE Magazine illustration highlighting scene lights and portable lighting, featuring a patrol SUV with emergency lights, multiple portable lighting devices, and an officer holding a spotlight.
Patrol•November 20, 2026

Scene Lights and Portable Lighting: Indispensable Tools for Patrol Vehicles

Carrying dedicated portable scene lights can make all the difference when illuminating a nighttime accident scene, conducting a roadside investigation, searching a wooded area, or managing other incidents before additional resources arrive. Here is what you need to know.

A black Blackhawk folding pocketknife displayed open and closed against a gray textured background, featuring a black blade, contoured handle, thumb stud, and pocket clip.
Patrol•November 19, 2026

Blackhawk Showcases Officer Carry Slide Lock Folder

Blackhawk’s Officer Carry slide lock folder is a back-to-basics folder that offers the perfect middle ground of lightweight, positive manual operation, and multi-purpose performance built around a D2 steel blade.

A Folds of Honor North Texas gala features two speakers onstage beneath patriotic banners, with America 250 branding, foundation sponsor logos, and guests seated at banquet tables in the foreground.
Patrol•November 19, 2026

Folds of Honor North Texas Gala Brings Community Together at AT&T Stadium, Raising $4 Million for Military and First Responder Families

The 2026 Folds of Honor North Texas Gala featured an inspiring evening honoring service, sacrifice, and the power of education, and raised $4 million to provide scholarships to the spouses and children of America's fallen or disabled military members and first responders.

Ad Loading...
A law enforcement patrol drone with green navigation lights flies above a city skyline at dusk, with a brightly illuminated high-rise building in the background.
Patrol•November 19, 2026

Forsyth County Sheriff Establishes First U.S. A2Z AirDock Network, Expanding its DFR Capabilities

The Forsyth County Sheriff’s Office, North Carolina, has launched the nation’s first A2Z Drone Delivery AirDock network. The dedicated network for drone-as-first-responder missions supports a fleet of A2Z Longtail Patrol drones.

POLICE Magazine graphic featuring a close-up of a tick on human skin with the headline “Tiny Creature, Big Threat” and subtitle “What officers need to know about ticks and alpha-gal syndrome.”
Patrol•November 4, 2026

The Threat That Fits Under Your Fingernail

What cops need to know about alpha-gal, the tick-borne allergy that can turn an ordinary exposure into a problem weeks or months later.

Bradenton, Florida, Police Department’s September 2026 Officers of the Month: Sergeant Andres Perez and Officers Rosey Bautista, Michael Wall, and Alexandra Fallacaro, pictured in uniform beside American flags.
Patrol•October 30, 2026

NLEOMF Honors September 2026 Officers of the Month

Four Bradenton Police Department officers were selected as the NLEOMF Officers of the Month for September 2026 for a nighttime water rescue.

Ad Loading...
BLACKHAWK! Mini EDC multitools displayed in tan and black, showing open pliers, knives, and other tools alongside their folded configurations against a textured gray background with the BLACKHAWK! logo.
Patrol•October 29, 2026

Blackhawk Debuts Mini EDC Pocket Multi-Tool

The Blackhawk Mini EDC Pocket Multi-Tool stows easily in pants pockets thanks to a sturdy stainless steel pocket clip and incorporates several essential/emergency tools into a single, high-mobility unit.

Team Wendy EXFIL Endurance ballistic helmet in olive green with tactical rails and chin strap, displayed alongside the Team Wendy logo and product headline against a textured black-and-gray background.
Patrol•October 23, 2026

Team Wendy Introduces the EXFIL Endurance Ballistic Helmet, Engineered to Reduce the Burden of Extended Wear

Team Wendy has launched its EXFIL Endurance, a new lightweight ballistic helmet engineered to deliver protection, comfort, and fit during demanding, extended operations.

Collage featuring paramedics, firefighters, police officers, and emergency vehicles surrounding the First Responders Children’s Foundation logo, highlighting the organization’s support for families of first responders.
Patrol•October 22, 2026

The First Responders Children’s Foundation National First Responders Day Roll Call of Heroes Ceremony Returns to Times Square, NYC

First Responders Children’s Foundation (FRCF), in collaboration with T-Mobile, will host the Roll Call of Heroes ceremony in Times Square to commemorate National First Responders Day on Wednesday, Oct. 28. During the event, FRCF will present 18 Hero Awards.

Ad Loading...
Streamlight promotional graphic showcasing four lighting products: TLR-3X, PolyTac 1X, ProTac Rail Mount 1L-X, and ProTac Rail Mount VIR Pro, displayed against an orange and black background with the Streamlight logo.
Patrol•October 22, 2026

Streamlight to Showcase Newest Lighting Products for Law Enforcement Professionals at IACP 2026

Streamlight will showcase its newest lights for law enforcement at the International Association of Chiefs of Police Annual Conference & Expo. Featured lights will include the TLR-3 X, the PolyTac 1X, and more.