Police Magazine Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Overlooked Legal Nuggets

From time to time, we get a really helpful decision that can make our jobs easier, and yet few people seem to learn about it or realize its significance. Here are 10 such decisions from the U.S. Supreme Court.

May 4, 2016
Overlooked Legal Nuggets

Photo: ©istockphoto.com

6 min to read


Based on an old proverb, "Bad news travels fast," John D. Loudermilk wrote (and Johnny Cash recorded) a song called, "Bad News." The song included the line, "Bad news travels like wildfire, good news travels slow."

That's true in the legal and law enforcement community. If the Supreme Court issues an unfavorable ruling like Missouri v. McNeely (requiring search warrants for forced blood in DUI cases) or Riley v. California (requiring search warrants to examine arrestees' cell phones), the news spreads quickly, and there's a rush to comply with the new restrictions.

Ad Loading...

But from time to time, we get a really helpful decision that can make our jobs easier, and yet few people seem to learn about it or realize its significance. Here are 10 such decisions from the U.S. Supreme Court (in reverse chronological order). I'm including the year when each ruling was issued, so you can judge for yourself how slowly the good news has traveled (ask yourself how many of these principles you already knew).

Howes v. Fields (2012)
Interrogating officers need not give full Miranda warnings to, or obtain waivers from, a sentenced prisoner who is taken from his cell to an interview room, as long as no additional restraints are imposed and the prisoner is told he need not answer questions and can return to his cell whenever he wants. "Serving a term of imprisonment, without more, is not enough to constitute Miranda custody. Taking a prisoner aside for questioning does not necessarily convert a noncustodial situation into one in which Miranda applies."

Scott v. Harris (2007)
For Fourth Amendment purposes, if the driver of a pursued vehicle is endangering pedestrians or other motorists, officers do not have to engage in lengthy, dangerous, high-speed pursuits until the driver either gives up, runs out of gas, or crashes his vehicle. "Instead, we lay down a more sensible rule: A police officer's attempt [such as with spikes or PIT maneuver] to terminate a dangerous high-speed car chase that threatens the lives of innocent bystanders does not violate the Fourth Amendment, even when it places the fleeing motorist at risk of serious injury or death."

Devenpeck v. Alford (2004)
If your search or seizure is not justifiable on the grounds you subjectively relied on, evidence need not be suppressed, nor civil liability imposed, if the search or seizure is objectively justifiable on other grounds. "Our cases make clear that an arresting officer's state of mind (except for the facts that he knows) is irrelevant to the existence of probable cause. That is to say, his subjective reason for making the arrest [detention, search, seizure, etc.] need not be the criminal offense as to which the known facts provide probable cause. Subjective intent of the officer is simply no basis for invalidating an arrest [etc.]."

Atwater v. Lago Vista (2001)
Regardless of whether an offense is an infraction, a misdemeanor, or a felony, a custodial arrest supported by probable cause does not violate the Fourth Amendment. "If an officer has probable cause to believe that an individual has committed even a very minor criminal offense [seat belt violation] in his presence, he may, without violating the Fourth Amendment, arrest the offender."

Ad Loading...

Arkansas v. Sullivan (2001)
If you have PC to arrest for a traffic violation or other minor charge, you may make a "pretext arrest" on that charge, just to give you authority to search incident to arrest, hoping to find evidence of more serious charges on which the person can then also be arrested. "A traffic-violation arrest will not be rendered invalid by the fact that it was a mere pretext for a narcotics search."

Richards v. Wisconsin (1997)
If your search warrant affidavit establishes reasonable suspicion that knocking and announcing before entry could endanger officers or permit destruction of evidence or escape, the magistrate can issue a "no-knock" warrant. "In order to justify a no-knock entry, the police must have a reasonable suspicion that knocking and announcing their presence, under the particular circumstances, would be dangerous or futile, or that it would inhibit the effective investigation of the crime by, for example, allowing the destruction of evidence."

Whren v. U.S. (1996)
When you lack reasonable suspicion of criminal activity to justify a vehicle stop, you can rely on observed traffic violations to justify a "pretext stop," and your subjective motivation of furthering a criminal investigation doesn't invalidate the stop. "We have been unwilling to entertain Fourth Amendment challenges based on the actual motivations of individual officers. The Fourth Amendment allows certain actions to be taken in certain circumstances, whatever the officer's subjective intent."

Illinois v. Perkins (1990)
After arrest and before the suspect's Sixth Amendment right to counsel attaches (indictment or first court appearance), you may place the suspect into a recorded cell with an undercover officer posing as his cellmate, and there is no need to Mirandize before that officer begins eliciting incriminating statements. "We hold that an undercover law enforcement officer posing as a fellow inmate need not give Miranda warnings to an incarcerated suspect before asking questions that may elicit incriminating responses."

Michigan v. Long (1983)
As you know, you can frisk a detainee for weapons based on reasonable suspicion that he may be armed and dangerous. But did you also know you may "frisk" a stopped vehicle based on reasonable suspicion that it may contain a weapon, potentially accessible by a dangerous suspect? "The search of the passenger compartment of an automobile, limited to those areas in which a weapon may be placed or hidden, is permissible if the police officer possesses a reasonable belief based on specific facts which, together with rational inferences, reasonably warrant the officer in believing that the suspect is dangerous and may gain immediate control of weapons."

Ad Loading...

Rawlings v. Kentucky (1980)
A search incident to arrest can lawfully be made even before the suspect is arrested, provided there is PC to arrest before the search begins. "Once police clearly have probable cause to place a defendant under arrest, [and] where the formal arrest follows quickly on the heels of the challenged search, we do not believe it particularly important that the search preceded the arrest, rather than vice versa."

Combining Legal Principles

Sometimes, multiple rulings combine to justify police conduct that might initially appear to be unreasonable. For example, while following the car of a suspect you think is carrying drugs, you see him make an illegal turn, and you make a stop. Believing you had reasonable suspicion of drug activity to make the stop and PC to justify a search, you find narcotics in his pocket, and then arrest him on drug charges. He moves to suppress on Fourth Amendment grounds, and the magistrate finds that you had insufficient facts to justify a narcotics stop and search. How should the court rule?

Under Devenpeck and Whren, the traffic violation objectively justifies the stop, regardless of your subjective motivation. Under Atwater, you had PC to arrest for the illegal turn. Per Sullivan, arrest for the traffic violation justifies the narcotics search. And Rawlings allowed the search to occur prior to arrest. Defendant's motion should be denied.

Moral: Don't overlook the good news.

Ad Loading...

Devallis Rutledge is a former police officer and veteran prosecutor who currently serves as special counsel to the Los Angeles County district attorney. He is the author of 12 books, including "Investigative Constitutional Law."

Subscribe to our newsletter

More Patrol

Graphic titled “5 Things to Know When Buying Backup Lights” featuring a compact Streamlight flashlight attached to tactical gear. Police Law Enforcement Solutions branding appears in the lower corner against a dark, dramatic background.
PatrolMay 21, 2026

5 Things to Know When Buying Backup Lights for Patrol Use

What is the value of a backup light, and what do you need to consider when selecting one? These smaller lights are invaluable as a secondary or special-purpose light and can be easily carried in a pocket or clipped to MOLLE gear, a key chain, shirt, or a vest.

Read More →
graphic honoring fallen law enforcement officers featuring a uniformed officer holding a folded American flag, with bold text reading “2026 Roll Call of Heroes” and “363 Fallen Officers Honored,” alongside the National Law Enforcement Officers Memorial Fund logo.
PatrolMay 14, 2026

363 Fallen Officers Honored During National Police Week

In case you missed NELOMF’s annual Candlelight Vigil, here are all 363 names of the fallen officers whose names were added to the National Law Enforcement Officers Memorial this year.

Read More →
Graphic honoring New York City Police Department officers as “Officer of the Month” for March 2026. The image features portraits of Chief Aaron Edwards and Sergeant Luis Navarro alongside department and recognition text.
PatrolMay 14, 2026

NYPD Officers Who Responded Quickly During IED Incident Recognized as NLEOMF Officers of the Month

Chief Aaron Edwards and Sgt. Luis Navarro were recognized by NLEOMF as Officers of the Month for their response during an IED incident and their actions that helped prevent harm to the public.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Infographic summarizing results from a national survey on policing reputation. Ten key findings cover public trust, communication, demographics, media influence, local policing, AI concerns, and emergency response, using charts, icons, and statistics throughout.
PatrolMay 14, 2026

National Police Survey Reveals How Americans View Policing Today

A new national survey offers a comprehensive look at how Americans view policing. The study uncovers public sentiment toward local vs. federal police, communications, crisis response, the use of AI in policing, and more.

Read More →
Product image of a Streamlight TLR-7 X tactical flashlight on a dark background. The compact black weapon-mounted light is shown in close-up beneath the Streamlight logo, highlighting its lens, controls, and mounting hardware.
PatrolMay 14, 2026

Streamlight TLR-7 X Selected as Standard Issue Pistol Light by Canadian Federal Police

The Canadian Federal Police will be adding a new duty pistol system, which will include Streamlight’s TLR-7 X and a Glock 45 MOS 7 pistol with a red dot sight.

Read More →
poeple dressed in dark clothing holding candles during a candlelight vigil.
PatrolMay 8, 2026

Fallen Law Enforcement Officers from Across the Country to be Honored During 38th Annual Candlelight Vigil on May 13th in Washington, D.C.

The National Law Enforcement Officers Memorial Fund (NLEOMF) will honor 363 fallen officers who have died in the line of duty as their names are added to the National Law Enforcement Officers Memorial during the annual Candlelight Vigil on May 13.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Black small medical bag with supplies and a tourniquet at right on a wood table and a large headline at left What Should Be In Your IFAK?
Patrolby Wayne ParhamMay 1, 2026

What Should Be in Your IFAK?

What should every officer include in an IFAK? Sydney Vail, M.D., a veteran trauma surgeon and former SWAT surgeon, explains which components are needed and which are not, and stresses training.

Read More →
flashlight turn un and submerged in puddle with rain falling.
PatrolApril 30, 2026

Olight Releases 2 New Baton Variants & the ArkPro Ultra Onyx Black

Olight has added two new lights to the Baton Series, the Baton 4 and the Baton Ultra. One new Baton features up to 1,600 lumens on turbo, and the other 1,800.

Read More →
Black tactical helmet with bright explosion behind it to the left, Team Wendy logo top right, and headline Recon Tactical Bump Helmet
PatrolApril 30, 2026

Team Wendy Reveals New RECON Tactical Bump Helmet

Team Wendy’s new RECON Tactical bump helmet is configurable by color, retention, and accessories for rescue, tactical, and military mission needs. It features Zorbium foam pads, shell vents, and lattice cooling pads that balance impact absorption, airflow, and long-wear support.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Black military style leather boot against a blue cobblestone background with a white Garmont Tactical logo.
PatrolApril 30, 2026

Garmont Tactical Introduces the T8 Specter LE Zip for LE Professionals

Garmont Tactical has a new 8-inch duty boot with a side zipper, the T8 Specter LE Zip. The boot is available now and features ankle support in a standard duty profile with polishable leather.

Read More →