Man Gets Life for 1996 Killing of N.C. Officer
On Oct. 5, 1996, Scott Vincent Sica fired a 9 mm Beretta handgun nine times at police Sgt. Gregory Keith Martin during a traffic stop, according to testimony in Yadkin Superior Court. Sica was 20 at the time; Martin was 30.
A Florida man must spend the rest of his life in prison for the execution-style murder of a Jonesville, N.C., police officer 17 years ago, under a plea deal Tuesday that avoided the death penalty.
On Oct. 5, 1996, Scott Vincent Sica fired a 9 mm Beretta handgun nine times at police Sgt. Gregory Keith Martin during a traffic stop, according to testimony in Yadkin Superior Court. Sica was 20 at the time; Martin was 30.
Tom Horner, the Yadkin County district attorney, told the Winston-Salem Journal after the sentencing that he could not talk about the deal because two others –– Marc Peterson Oldroyd, of Rockwood, Tenn., and Brian Eugene Whittaker, of Cape Coral, Fla. — also face charges, including first-degree murder, in connection with Martin’s death. Their court dates have not been set.
On Sept. 17, 2012, Oldroyd’s cousin, Alicia Smith, contacted the FBI after she saw on America’s Most Wanted that a reward for information leading to the killers was being offered. The tip — and previous detective work done by Det. Ron Perry and others of the Jonesville Police Department, SBI, FBI and Elkin Police Department — helped lead to Sica's arrest.
More Investigations
Fugitive Wanted in 1988 $1.3 Million Vault Heist Identified by FBI Laboratory
The FBI Laboratory Latent Prints Unit positively identified a man, who died in December, as the suspect wanted in the theft of $1.3 million in cash from an armored car service in 1988. He had previously been featured on Unsolved Mysteries and America’s Most Wanted.
Read More →
Suspect Arrested in Charlie Kirk Assassination
Authorities arrested a 22-year-old Utah man for the killing of Charlie Kirk just 33 hours after the assassination in what FBI Director Kash Patel called a historic time period. “This is what happens when you let good cops be cops,” Patel said.
Read More →
More Than 7,000 Tips Provided to Kirk Assassination Investigation
More than 7,000 tips were provided to the investigation by the day after the assassination of Charlie Kirk on a Utah college campus on Wednesday. The FBI has not received that much help from the public since the Boston Marathon bombings.
Read More →
Idaho AG Will Not Pursue Charges Against 4 Officers Who Fatally Shot Nonverbal Autistic Teen Armed with a Knife
The Idaho Office of the Attorney General has concluded its investigation into the fatal officer-involved shooting that killed a 17-year-old teen who was armed with a knife. Officers did not know the teen suffered from developmental delays, autism, and other conditions.
Read More →
The Role of Forensics in Disaster Victim Identification
Heidi Sievers, of Columbia Southern University, explains disaster victim identification and how scientific work bridges critical gaps when visual recognition, one of the least reliable methods of identification, is rendered impossible by the conditions of the disaster.
Read More →
Crimes Against Children Detective Named June 2025 Officer of the Month by NLEOMF
The case began in March and culminated with multiple search warrants and arrests on June 10, 2025. This case ran between Virginia and New York with multiple victims throughout the United States.
Read More →
2 Officers Injured in Attack at Texas Border Patrol Station
A McAllen Police officer was shot in the leg during the attack. A Border Patrol officer and a non-sworn employee were injured, according to a Department of Homeland Security.
Read More →
Multi-State Law Enforcement Operation Rescues 70 Human Trafficking Victims
The operation involved the execution of 25 search warrants and disrupted business at 26 “illicit massage businesses,” the Human Trafficking Training Center reports.
Read More →
2 Ohio Officers Shot During Traffic Stop, Suspect at Large
According to the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office, the suspect has been charged with one count of attempted murder and two counts of felonious assault.
Read More →DOJ Rescues 115 Sexually Exploited Children, Arrests 205 Offenders
“The Department of Justice will never stop fighting to protect victims — especially child victims — and we will not rest until we hunt down, arrest, and prosecute every child predator...,” Attorney General Pamela Bondi.
Read More →