POLICE Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

High Court Decision Backs Law Enforcement

What do you call a federal court that changes facts to fit its argument and issues rulings so far outside established law that it's routinely chastised and reversed by a higher court? In California we know it as the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.

Editor's Note: This blog post first appeared on the  Los Angeles Police Protective League's website .

What do you call a federal court that changes facts to fit its argument and issues rulings so far outside established law that it's routinely chastised and reversed—often unanimously and without a hearing—by a higher court? You might call that court lawless and reckless, but here in California we know it as the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.

Ad Loading...

The latest reversal of the Ninth Circuit involved  Burbank police officers  responding to a reported rumor of a student threatening a school shooting. Officers went to the home of the student, who'd been absent from school for two weeks, and were met by his mother and the student. She spoke to them outside the house but refused to invite the officers inside. When they asked if there were guns in the house, the mother turned and fled inside. The alarmed officers followed her inside, where they proceeded to interview her and the student for about 10 minutes before determining the school shooting threat was unfounded. No search of the residence was conducted.

The family sued the officers for entering the house without a warrant. The District Court found that the officers had qualified immunity because they faced a "rapidly evolving incident." But last year, the Ninth Circuit reversed this in a 2-1 decision, finding the officers' actions unreasonable.

In an unsigned,  unanimous opinion  that was a stinging reversal of the Ninth Circuit, the U.S. Supreme Court ordered that the case against the officers be dismissed. The Supreme Court first took the Ninth Circuit to task for misapplying case law, writing, "No decision of this Court has found a Fourth Amendment violation on facts even roughly comparable to those present in this case. On the contrary, some of our opinions may be read as pointing in the opposition direction."

The Court then went on to call out the Ninth Circuit for changing the facts in the case to fit its legal conclusion: "Although the panel majority purported to accept the findings of the District Court, it changed those findings in several key respects." The court concluded by rebuking the Ninth Circuit for its "entirely unrealistic" analysis of the incident and its "second guessing" of the officers.

In 2011, the Ninth Circuit was reversed in 19 out of 26 cases, with 12 of the reversals being unanimous. Some quotes from recent U.S. Supreme Court reversals highlight the lawlessness of the Ninth Circuit: one decision was termed " as inexplicable as it is unexplained ;" in another, the factual assertions by the Ninth Circuit were " simply false "; and in a third, it was found that the Ninth Circuit's opinion undermined confidence because " judicial disregard is inherent in the opinion of the Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit here under review ."

It is troubling when a reversal is unanimous because it is a clear sign that legal precedent was completely ignored.

Ad Loading...
Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Blogposts

Inside the Badge by Wayne ParhamJuly 19, 2024

Preventing Heat Injury in Police K-9s

In the relentless heat of summer and even early fall in some parts of the country, officers face the important task of protecting their K-9 partners while working in sweltering temperatures. Recognizing changes in a dog’s behavior is the key.

Read More →
Inside the Badge by StaffDecember 19, 2023

Why Your Agency Needs to Attend the ILEETA Conference

ILEETA is a complete resource for trainers to address trainers' needs. Its mission is to enhance the skills and safety of criminal justice practitioners while fostering stronger and safer communities.

Read More →
Inside the Badge by David GriffithNovember 28, 2023

IACP 2023: New Training Products

Technologies for improving law enforcement training and training management were some of the highlights at this year's show.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Inside the Badge by Wayne ParhamOctober 27, 2023

Initial Results Released from MSP 2024 Police Vehicle Testing

The 2024 pursuit-rated vehicles--all pickup trucks or SUVs, including two battery electric models the Chevrolet Blazer EV AWD and Ford Mustang Mach-E--were put through their paces.

Read More →
Inside the Badge by Wayne ParhamJune 26, 2023

Officer Safety Considerations Related to Alternative-Fuel Vehicles

As more alternative-fuel and hybrid vehicles hit the road, police and other first responders need to understand that they are no more dangerous than conventional vehicles. However, there are certain safety considerations every cop should know.

Read More →
Inside the Badge by Wayne ParhamJune 9, 2023

Garmont Working to Grow LE Market Presence

Garmont Tactical has found wide acceptance by military boot buyers, but now the company is trying to better respond to the needs of police officers. Many cops now are not fans of 8-inch boots, so Garmont is adapting.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Inside the Badge by StaffJune 7, 2023

Publisher’s Note: Our Commitment to You

Through our magazine and website and our Police Technology eXchange event, we promise to provide you with information and access to resources to help you do your job safer and better.

Read More →
Inside the Badge by Wayne ParhamJune 2, 2023

10 Tips for Responding to Mental Health Crisis Calls

The Harris County Sheriff's Office is a model for other agencies that want to learn about crisis intervention and mental health crisis response. Sgt. Jose Gomez shares the story of their programs and provides 10 tips for mental health crisis call response

Read More →
Inside the Badge by Wayne ParhamMay 22, 2023

5 Things to Know When Buying Concealed-Carry or Off-Duty Holsters

Mike Barham, of Galco Holsters, shares five important considerations to keep in mind when you buy off-duty concealed or plain-clothes carry holsters.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
10 Tips for Reviewing Use-of-Force Reports - Police Law Enforcement Solutions graphic
Inside the Badge by Wayne ParhamMay 10, 2023

10 Tips for Reviewing Use-of-Force Reports

While the burden of accurately reporting use-of-force situations is on an individual deputy or officer, the person reviewing those reports shares in the responsibility of making sure the reporting is done properly, with clear details included.

Read More →