On July 16, 2009, Cambridge police were dispatched to a residence on Ware Street after receiving a call from a neighbor who reported that two unknown black male adults were on the front porch of a residence and that one of the subjects was attempting to enter the front door by bodily force.
When Sgt. Crowley and other officers of the Cambridge PD walked up to the porch of the residence, he observed and encountered Gates, whom he found in the foyer of the home. When the sergeant identified himself, explained the reason for the officers' presence, and asked Gates to step outside to speak with him, the professor replied, "No. I will not."
When Crowley again explained that he was responding to a possible break-in, Gates replied, "Why, because I'm a black man in America?" When Crowley directed Gates to produce some identification to verify that he was in fact the resident, Gates ignored him and began to make a phone call. The sergeant overheard Gates telling someone on the other end of the line that he was "dealing with a racist police officer in his home."
Once additional officers, including Harvard University Police officers, arrived on scene, Gates reluctantly produced his Harvard University faculty card.
Based upon this information Gates gave them, the Harvard PD officers were able to verify Gates' identity and home address. Sgt. Crowley then apologized to Gates for the inconvenience, and he and the assisting officers left the premises. This should have been the end of this encounter, but it wasn't—not because of anything the officers did, but because the incensed and self-important Professor Gates just wouldn't let it go.
As the officers walked away, Gates came out onto his front porch and began to loudly rant and rave about Crowley's racial bias, calling him a racist police officer. Crowley took this opportunity to warn Gates that he was now creating a disturbance and advised the agitated professor to calm down or face arrest. When Gates continued his tirade, Crowley had apparently had enough of the professor's belligerent attitude and arrested him for disorderly conduct. It was, in my opinion, a well-deserved and lawful arrest.