FREE e-Newsletter
Important News - Hot Topics
Get them Now!

Tactical Pants - Galls
A popular choice for public safety professionals, the Galls Tactical Pants are...

Reviews : Arsenal

SIG Sauer P238 Pistol

This very concealable single-action backup gun owes much of its looks to the 1911.

February 28, 2010  |  by Paul Scarlata - Also by this author

PHOTOS: Nathan Reynolds and Dick Cole

The use of backup guns is becoming more and more common with American law enforcement personnel. The reasons for carrying a backup gun are simple: If your primary weapon is snatched, runs out of ammo, or malfunctions you don't have to face your attacker(s) with only a less-lethal weapon or harsh language. You draw your backup gun and get back into the fight.

Many agencies allow their officers to carry a backup gun, while others require it. The most popular types of backup guns are small revolvers and semi-auto pistols, and SIG Sauer has just introduced a small semi-auto that deserves a serious look from any officer or agency considering such weapons: the P238.

In addition to being used for backup, the P238 would be very practical for plainclothes officers who need a "deep cover" weapon. It would also be a good choice for an off-duty gun. Not only do many agencies allow or even encourage off-duty carry, but some (e.g. the NYPD) require their officers to be armed at all times. This pistol will satisfy this requirement, too.

1911 Looks

Unlike so many of the new pistols on today's market, the P238 does not make use of a polymer frame or components and does not have a double-action-only trigger. Instead, this very traditional pistol uses a stainless steel frame mated to an alloy frame and has a single-action trigger mechanism with an external, thumb safety. In fact, a cursory examination of the SIG reveals that it is nothing more than a (very) mini 1911.

But while the P238 is a 1911 clone externally, when you disassemble the pistol you find the barrel locks up via the chamber hood moving up into, and bearing on, the front of the ejection port as the slide reciprocates rearward. This is a much simpler locking system than the 1911's lugs on the barrel, and SIG was one of the first companies to use this system in its pistols.

Operation and Carry

The operating drill for the P238 is the same as the 1911. You insert a magazine, rack the slide to chamber a cartridge, and then engage the thumb safety. The pistol can be carried this way (condition 1), which allows you to draw and fire it very quickly and accurately.

If you don't care for this mode of carry, you can carry it with a loaded magazine, chamber empty and the hammer down (condition 3), which requires you to rack the slide to chamber a round before it can be fired. Both modes have their proponents and critics, but with proper training the single-action 1911-type pistol is one of the safest handguns ever designed.

The P238 is chambered for the popular .380 ACP. This round has been around since 1912 and while it was once considered a low-end defensive cartridge, its performance has been significantly improved thanks to advances in bullet technology and modern propellants. I'm not saying it's the equal of the .40 S&W, but I'm sure most would agree that it sure beats the hell out of a baton as a backup to your duty pistol.

On the Range

SIG Sauer's Kathy McQueeney kindly supplied me with a P238 to evaluate for POLICE magazine. As you would expect from a company with SIG Sauer's reputation, the P238 displayed first class materials, fit, and finish. The slide was easy to retract, the controls all worked positively, and the sights and ergonomics were above average for this class of pistol.

While it is hardly germane for a pistol of this size, I test fired it for accuracy from a rest at 10 yards with UMC 95-grain FMJ ammo. I was pleased to see that, despite the P238's small size and short grip, I was able to produce decently centered groups running from just under three inches to four inches in size.

My good friend Paul Brinkman, a former firearms training officer for the Riverside County (Calif.) Sheriff's Department,  helped me run the little SIG through its paces at our gun club. Using a mixture of the remaining ammo, we ran a series of drills at three, five, and seven yards, firing the pistol with both supported and unsupported grips. All drawing was done from concealment using a Galco IWB holster.

As both of us compete regularly in Action Pistol matches with 1911 pistols, we found the little P238's operating drill almost second nature...just a bit smaller. Or as my friend Paul put it, "It's really nice having all the controls located and operated exactly as you're used to them." The magazines dropped free when the release was pushed-slide forward or locked back.

The sights were large and easy to pick up, which enabled both of us to perforate targets in a very pleasing manner while the controls were well located and convenient to manipulate. We were both surprised with how controllable recoil was in a pistol weighing only 15 ounces. Both of us were able to get back on target quickly and make accurate follow-up shots with aplomb.

We ran about 300 rounds of FMJ and JHP rounds through it with utter reliability. In fact, the only functioning problem we experienced were a few failures of the slide to lock back on an empty magazine. But this was a new, out-of-the-box pistol and I would expect such minor problems to clear up once it is broken in.

On the Street

I used the P238 as my regular concealed carry gun for several weeks and can report that it served admirably in this role. Its flat cross-section made it easy to conceal even under light clothing and thanks to its light weight I was hardly aware that I was carrying a gun.

Whether you are a uniformed officer looking for a backup gun, a detective who needs a small handgun for deep concealment, or a cop who needs an off-duty gun that is easy to carry when wearing civilian clothing, I believe the P238 would be a very practical choice. 

Paul Scarlata has served as an auxiliary police officer and is a frequent contributor to POLICE.

Visit SIG Sauer online

Request more info about this product / service / company

Comments (7)

Displaying 1 - 7 of 7

P-Smith @ 1/22/2011 6:05 PM

I am thinking of purchasing a P238HD for my wife and went online to see if I could find a review. Having police recomend the exact gun I picked out for her really helped me in my decession. I will purchase it tomorrow! Thanks

David J. Holland @ 2/1/2011 8:41 AM

Retired police major with 55 years police service. Carry the Sig P238 as a defensive weapon with Hornby Critical Defense ammo. Weapon is easy to carry and Sig reliability. Still have my S & W .38 snubbie on my night stand for home defense. Unlike the 1911 method of carry, ie round in chamber, safetyon or just in mag to be loaded when pulled from the pant pocket, the snubbie is always ready to go with no worries of failing to fire as autos sometimes occur. Would never give this weapon up (snubbie) but the Sig is flat and easy to carry in pant pocket. Rate the story 4 stars.

Jeff thorne @ 3/24/2012 4:36 AM

Nice little carry piece better than Tauruses ruggers keltecs 380 sig done a good job on this gun

Milt Rogers @ 1/26/2013 4:50 PM

I am most interested in acquiring a P238. It looks like an ideal concealed carry weapon (for which I have a license). Only problem is I can't find one in the entire state of CO (missed one by one day). Is there any way you can help?
Milt Rogers

stormy @ 5/11/2013 4:07 PM

i got one of the first in alaska.. it will jump with a full load.. does not cycle with reloaded lead cast my carry with a ankle holster.. spend the money on sig magazines only note unlike a 1911 and like the 220 sao it can be loaded or unloaded without taking it off safe.. i really like mine gave my daughter and my son both one they both have had to turn down buyer request..although i dont buy for resale if you think that is a reason this absoulatly is the best wt.. and size per dollar you can buy.. and the sights are ten times better than the colt mustang

Jeff W @ 10/31/2014 8:09 AM

I have some nerve damage in my right hand so I was looking for a conceal carry handgun that was easy to shoot with not a lot of recoil. This P238 fills the bill perfectly. Mine has rubber grips, night sights and the extended magazine which allows me to have 3 fingers on the grip for better control. This gun shoots great, very little recoil, right on target and it functions flawlessly. I prefer this over the P938 in 9mm because it is easier to control and in guns that are just about the same dimensions and weight the P938 is a little harder to control and get back on target then the milder shooting P238.

Teresa @ 3/19/2015 2:05 PM

I bought one at a Pawn Shop I do business with. I knew as soon as I held it, it was MY gun. Racks butter smooth. I have small hands and really no upper body strength, and this little baby is awesome. I carry it with me all the time (yes I have CHL) and so comfortable with it that I fell asleep wearing it on the couch earlier today. I bought a belly band from The Well Armed Woman website...not as wide as a regular band and twice as comfortable. Wouldn't give up my gun for anything, as a matter of fact, I'm considering getting another when Texas passes the Open Carry Law.

Join the Discussion

POLICE Magazine does not tolerate comments that include profanity, personal attacks or antisocial behavior (such as "spamming" or "trolling"). This and other inappropriate content or material will be removed. We reserve the right to block any user who violates this, including removing all content posted by that user.
Police Magazine