FREE e-Newsletter
Important News - Hot Topics
Get them Now!

The Law Officer's Pocket Manual - Bloomberg BNA
This handy 4" x 6" spiral-bound manual offers examples showing how rules are...

Columns : In My Sights

Guilt, Shame, and the Crimefighter

Don't let past mistakes haunt your present and affect your future.

November 25, 2013  |  by Dave Smith - Also by this author

Illustration: Sequoia Blankenship
Illustration: Sequoia Blankenship

I am not Catholic, but as a young cop I coached wrestling at a Catholic school so I guess my keen sense of guilt is understandable. I feel bad about myriad issues, like not calling Mom enough. Guilt is a powerful thing and even though it may cause us a great deal of grief I hate to imagine our country without it.

There are lots of places in the world folks aren’t raised with guilt. These societies use something we know as "shame" to help maintain social order and control people's impulses. The two are distinct, yet often we confuse one for the other.

"Guilt" is a self-generated sense of judgment about ourselves and our actions or thoughts, while "shame" is a reflection of judgment about us from others. Things like honor killings and ritual suicides come from societies that set right a social order by giving those "shamed" a way to restore others' opinions about them, their families, their company, or their country, however extreme it may seem.

In our culture such practices are tough to understand, just as guilt may be an odd concept elsewhere. In shame/honor cultures one actually gains social standing by getting away with an otherwise bad act. Young Spartans successfully completed their initiation into manhood by murdering a slave; the rub was they had to get away with it. Shame didn't come from committing such a cruel act but only from the "mistake" of getting caught.

I am certainly happy we live in a "guilt" culture, since the residue of this guilt is something we hold very dear: trust. In fact, the United States has the highest level of trust in the world. The thing is, guilt just sitting in your heart or your gut isn’t good for you. From time to time we need to remember we have social norms for eliminating this simultaneously healthy and corrosive trait.

I don’t think you can ever rid yourself of all guilty feelings but it's good to eliminate the ones that really eat at you. Years ago I led a class mental rehearsal in which I took cadets through an armed confrontation where they end up shooting and killing an armed assailant. I had more than a few recruits quit the academy after that, but one in particular came to me with a very disturbing revelation.

In this cadet's head, when he pictured the paramedics working on his imaginary assailant he walked up and saw that the dying man was his brother, and he hadn’t been able to sleep since. I promptly sent this military veteran to a superb police psychologist. He returned shaking his head that he had never met a shrink like that but he felt 100% better and hadn’t had any problems sleeping since his "treatment."

It seems the treatment required him to call his brother in the presence of the good doctor and ask for his brother’s forgiveness. Apparently, as young children the soon-to-be deputy had seriously injured his younger brother by accident and the haunting guilt had lived just below the surface ever since. He called his sibling, who didn’t even remember the event, and asked forgiveness. He got, in fact, an affirmation of brotherly love as well and he hung up the phone, got his chit signed, and headed back to enjoy a full career in law enforcement.

What’s that you say? It wasn’t really his brother’s forgiveness he needed? He needed to forgive himself? Exactly, my friends. And maybe you need to start with that to begin clearing your mind of some of the guilt that may haunt you.

Confession, contrition, forgiveness, and redemption are commonly listed as keys to healing a guilty conscience or heart, but it always begins with you forgiving yourself first. I can’t have you hesitating in an armed confrontation because of some deep-seated guilt that makes you believe you deserve to lose or should be punished.

If you also need the forgiveness of someone else then seek that as well. But your mind needs to focus on positive outcomes in critical situations, and freeing yourself from guilt is a good first step. Now if we could just get our politicians to feel either guilt or shame…

Dave Smith is an internationally recognized law enforcement trainer and is the creator of "JD Buck Savage." You can follow Buck on Twitter at @thebucksavage.

Comments (3)

Displaying 1 - 3 of 3

Leonrd Mather @ 11/28/2013 9:48 AM

Commenting as a Forensic Psychologist (PhD from the Catholic University of America), this article is right on target and quintessentially focused. Kudos to the writer(s)! Neurotic guilt can cause one to have a "need to suffer." In short, two steps forward and three steps back. One thought-like prayer to say before falling asleep is: "I rest easy at night knowing all the people I treated badly had it coming." (That was a joke; not meant to be serious).

Dean Collins @ 12/2/2013 9:43 AM

I don't know what Catholic 'guilt' is still left in the Catholic church. I can't remember any significant or constant teaching or preaching about sin and guilt since Vatican Council II ended in 1965. Catholic coppers can ask themselves when was the last time they heard anything about sin/guilt. I survived an active shooter incident and never felt any guilt whatsoever about fulfilling my duty and my oath to protect and serve even though I had to take a human life. Suggest that Romans 13: 1-6 contains the answer: we are God's ministers doing his work here on earth. I have nothing to feel guilty about. I am still in active law enforcement since 1969 and an ordained Catholic deacon since 1984. Stay safe and continue to do the Lord's work.

Tom Alisankus @ 12/8/2013 5:06 AM

Being a good catholic, I too was raised on guilt. Granted, Vatican II may have curtailed that as a function of the religion, but my parents were raised from Vatican I. While I've come to terms with most of it, I still, after 33 years as a cop, always remember, 'there, but the grace of God go I.' More concerning for me, is despite all of the positive visualization about 'winning' every confrontation, in EVERY dream I've had where I'm confronted by a 'bad guy', my firearm ALWAYS malfunctions. Typically, the bullets just come out too slow. I always score above 90% at the range. I can't help but wonder if this isn't some resolution to the inner guilt conflict. Whatever it is, it worries me that, THAT'S what I will think about if, God forbid, I'm ever confronted like that in the conscious world.

Join the Discussion

POLICE Magazine does not tolerate comments that include profanity, personal attacks or antisocial behavior (such as "spamming" or "trolling"). This and other inappropriate content or material will be removed. We reserve the right to block any user who violates this, including removing all content posted by that user.

Other Recent Stories

Hurricane Response: Weathering the Storm
By the time Florence blew into Wilmington, a city of around 100,000 people, she was much...
Police Supporters
This holiday season you should know that most Americans support you and respect you.
Flying Cross: External Carrier Compatible Outerwear
How do you create outerwear that protects officers from the elements in all types of...

Police Magazine