FREE e-Newsletter
Important News - Hot Topics
Get them Now!

The Law Officer's Pocket Manual - Bloomberg BNA
This handy 4" x 6" spiral-bound manual offers examples showing how rules are...


Do We Still Need Batons?

Have TASERs and OC made the handheld impact weapon obsolete?

March 01, 2009  |  by - Also by this author

Training Gap

One thing the experts contacted for this article agree upon is that a lack of training and weapons proficiency has diminished the ability of officers to effectively wield impact weapons.

Indeed, now 18 years following the King incident, many use-of-force experts see the cause of that tragedy to be less a case of police abuse than an indictment of Officer William Powell's proficiency with the weapon. It's a problem we may see again, and you can bet that someone will be there to capture it on video.

"In academies, the actual use-of-force training (shooting, batons, pepper spray, etc.) usually gets shortchanged," notes Marquez. "So with the PR there's a lack of development of the high level of expertise that is necessary if you're going to carry it. For both guys and girls, that's a lot of baton that they don't want to mess with. So my recommendation is to go with an expandable baton like a Monadnock or an ASP."

Regardless of the striking weapon chosen, improper training may result in injuries to personnel, as well as civil damages. In the wake of one baton training session gone south, Brawley, Calif., ended up paying a medically retired officer $2.35 million in damages.

Planned Obsolescence

But perhaps the biggest threat to striking weapons is a growing perception that TASERs have mitigated their need, perhaps even rendered them obsolete to the minds of some.

Barry Brodd teaches defensive tactics for police, Army, Park Service rangers, regional parks, probation officers, the whole gamut of people. Brodd has noticed an over-reliance on the TASER and cites instances wherein the TASER has been deployed under less than ideal circumstances such as when a suspect is within a couple of feet of an officer and the probes can't spread far enough to create a good circuit.

"That eliminates any effective backup plan if the TASER is ineffective or if the darts don't hit the intended target," Brodd observes. "By then the suspect is right on top of you and the TASER is not effective in close quarters. Of course, it can be used as a contact stun device, but if this fails and the suspect gains control of the TASER, then what?"

Brodd says the answer to his concern is to prevent the situation in the first place using teamwork.

"We train if one officer is deploying a TASER, then the other officer is ready with lethal force. Or if the TASER is ineffective and the situation hasn't escalated to where lethal force would be justified, the second officer would use the baton. Especially with the expanding batons, the motion of expanding it is almost a type of visual escalation to let somebody know, 'Oh, don't hit me with that thing.'"

Marquez agrees that a telescoping baton can be a powerful persuader.

"Being an ASP trainer, I'm going to promote their products somewhat. I think the ASP 26-inch baton is a good tool. If you look at actual kinetic energy the batons deliver, the expandable batons deliver more kinetic energy than a PR; the PR is more a blunt type of baton. It takes a little more talent, a little more skill to use the PR properly, especially to use the short end of it."

Marquez says the argument over batons really has very little to do with their utility and more with administrative and public sentiment against the weapon.

Comments (4)

Displaying 1 - 4 of 4

rportillo @ 3/20/2009 6:41 PM

The baton has reached it's potential as a tool for police officers. With new technology and tools as the ASP, tasers, etc. it has outdated the baton. I have seen many PO loose the baton during altercations, riots, and other types of confrontations where PO's become victims as results of such. No need for them now.

David Moore S-55 @ 4/20/2009 1:51 AM

Very timely indeed! Great overview, well written, with solid facts. I plan on sharing this with contacts this way (PMO) - for use-of-force considerations (discussions) as being here in South Korea, presents additional challenges with off-installation policing Town Patrol (TP), and traffic for SOFA members. The SOFA concerns with limitations. Batons the very long kind are still used this way during demonstrations and crowd control efforts by KNP-Riot Police...Thanks!

michael @ 3/4/2011 12:17 AM

I still like my baton. I carry a 12" in my rear leg pocket and the pr-24.
I use my short baton, but not the pr-24. We are required to have the pr with us. I find the larger baton is difficult to use in most confrontations where as the smaller baton is great other then in a crowd control situation.

JHo79 @ 8/29/2013 9:58 PM

Batons have been a reliable and effective tool for law enforcement spanning generations and cultures

Join the Discussion

POLICE Magazine does not tolerate comments that include profanity, personal attacks or antisocial behavior (such as "spamming" or "trolling"). This and other inappropriate content or material will be removed. We reserve the right to block any user who violates this, including removing all content posted by that user.
Police Magazine