But Smith takes a more sympathetic view of the reasons officers commit suicide. He feels that because they want to continue to do their job, police officers ignore difficulties in their professional or personal lives for fear that acknowledging them could lead to their dismissals.
“Often, police officers feel all they can do is police work. If they’re having problems, they just force it and keep going,” he says.
In addition to all the other difficulties of the job, an officer’s proximity to traumatic experiences can magnify already existent problems, according to John Violanti, a professor at The University of Buffalo Department of Social and Preventative Medicine and a retired New York State trooper.
“Officers have many of the same problems that other people who commit suicide have, but the context of their job exacerbates those conditions and it makes it worse,” Violanti explains. “In that sense they’re more likely to commit suicide than someone in the general working population.”
Fraternity of Pain
But what about other public safety officers? Are they as prone to suicide as cops and for the same reasons?
Again because suicide is such a touchy subject, the numbers are hard to come by. Comparative statistics for police officers, firefighters, and rescue workers are difficult to find, but it’s well known that other public safety workers commit suicide as well.
Robert O’Donnell, the paramedic who rescued “Baby Jessica” McClure from an abandoned well in Midland, Texas, in 1987, killed himself in 1995. He is said to have suffered from post-traumatic stress disorder, a condition that also afflicts many police officers.
“Police officers see a lot of things that other people who are not officers would never see: human misery, traumatic events such as 9/11,” says Violanti. “The exposure that first responders get to these sorts of events are generally very close so that has an impact on their psychological well-being.”
Talking it Out
In Violanti’s research, he has found that law enforcement officers exposed to traumatic events think about suicide much more often than those who are not. But it doesn’t always take a traumatic event to drive someone to the breaking point.
Daniel W. Clark, department psychologist for the Washington State Patrol, believes frequently talking about day-to-day problems can help someone cope better with life in general. “What leads to life-and-death issues,” he says, “is when all the small stuff stacks up on us.”
Unfortunately, law enforcement culture, which puts emphasis on physical and emotional strength, can make it difficult for cops to talk about the small events that cause stress in their lives.
For a cop, even divulging perceived weaknesses to friends can be difficult. Admitting vulnerabilities to a psychologist is even more daunting, and police officers’ mistrust of anyone not in law enforcement makes speaking to mental health professionals even more difficult.
“Police officers are great help-givers, but they’re pretty poor help-seekers,” Clark says. “You have to fight against cops’ fears that something awful is going to happen if they do come forward,” adds Dr. Elizabeth K. White, psychologist with the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department.
White says this can be true of law enforcement officers seeking help for their friends, as well. “A colleague might blow it off, and tell himself his friend is just joking or will be OK in the morning, because he’s afraid of the consequences, that he might destroy someone’s career,” she explains. “They don’t want to step in so they hope it’s nothing and pray that they’re right. And then they feel awful if it turns out that it was something.”
Suicide intervention can be difficult with police officers. They are often afraid to admit their problems for fear of ending their law enforcement careers.
Because officers are so reluctant to seek out professional help, some agencies have established peer counseling programs. Fellow police officers are volunteering to take training classes in listening to their colleagues’ concerns and recognizing warning signs so they can refer them to mental health professionals if necessary. Experts say peer counseling is very effective because it’s a way to talk to someone who understands your feelings and concerns as a police officer and won’t tell anyone else what you have said.
Unfortunately, not all police officers are convinced that talking to anyone, not even a peer, is safe. They’ve heard too many stories about officers seeking help and then being passed over for promotions or even being fired for perceived mental instability.
Fighting the Stigma
They have good reason to be concerned. The stigma associated with seeking emotional help is not completely unfounded, and there is a tradition of cutting an agency’s losses by removing an officer from sensitive positions if he or she might possibly be a liability.
But agencies are making an effort to remove these obstacles to counseling, and it seems that the changes are working.
White says there is now less of a stigma attached to seeking help than there used to be. Part of this is generational. “Younger cops are more comfortable asking for assistance,” White says.
Older cops are more skeptical when it comes to counseling. But Sgt. Garry Collins, whose unit deals with suicide prevention at the San Diego Police Departement, believes veteran cops who have seen too many of their friends kill themselves over the years are starting to appreciate the psychological services that are now available to them.
But even if an at-risk police officer is willing to go see a psychologist, he or she doesn’t want to publicize the visit. For this reason, department psychologists are often placed far from department headquarters to protect confidentiality.
Case in point. When the Houston Police Department required employees to visit the department psychologist at an office in the police headquarters building, they were too scared to seek help. But once Houston PD moved its psychological services back to a separate building in another part of town, more officers decided to avail themselves of its services.
Not only are law enforcement officers afraid management might find out they’re seeking help, they don’t want their friends and colleagues to know about it either. And usually they don’t.
“It’s only when a peer counselor or psychologist feels drastic measures need to be taken to ensure an officer’s safety that the department needs to be brought in on what’s going on,” says White.
Clark likens a department’s view of officers seeking help for suicidal thoughts or depression to seeking help for alcoholism. “If you don’t seek help and you get tapped for a DUI early one morning, you’re toast. In all likelihood, they’re going to terminate you or severely reprimand you,” he says. “But if you come forward and say, ‘I have an alcohol problem; I need some help,’ I believe most agencies are going to say, ‘OK, we’ll get you some treatment that will square you away.’”
With suicide, an officer who seeks treatment can often be successfully treated for depression and be back on the job. But you have to seek help to receive help, and an agency has to provide services that an officer feels comfortable using to make a suicide awareness program work.
Still, despite a growing movement among agencies to offer counseling services to officers and educate them on the warning signs and the adverse effects of suicide on everyone involved, officers are still killing themselves. And that leaves everyone they knew with one overriding and ultimately unanswerable question: Why?
What Can You Do?
- Know the warning signs of suicide.
- Attend classes on depression and suicide if they are offered at your agency to help you identify risks and know how to deal with suicide in case it ever happens at your agency.
- Don't be afraid to suggest that friends seek help if you are concerned they may attempt suicide. There are many places where you can receive help anonymously if your friend doesn't want to go through the department.
- If your agency doesn't already offer a suicide awareness program, suggest that one be started. Contact local departments and ask them for advice and help in starting your agency's own program. Or talk to other smaller departments about creating a joint program to raise suicide awareness and offer shared psychological services.
Top 10 Reasons for Police Suicide
1. Death of a child or spouse
2. Loss of a child or spouse through divorce
3. Terminal illness
4. Responsibility for partner's death
5. Killing someone out of anger
7. Feeling all alone
8. Sexual accusation
9. Loss of job due to conviction of a crime
10. Being locked up
Suicide Prevention Resources:
American Foundation for Suicide Prevention
National Hopeline Network
National Police Suicide Foundation