FREE e-Newsletter
Important News - Hot Topics
Get them Now!
Bob Parker

Bob Parker

Lt. Robert Parker served with the Omaha (Neb.) PD for 30 years and commanded the Emergency Response Unit. He is responsible for training thousands of law enforcement instructors in NTOA's Patrol Response to Active Shooters courses.

Jose Medina

Jose Medina

Officer Jose Medina is an active member of the Piscataway (N.J.) Police Department's SWAT team and runs Awareness Protective Consultants (Team APC) tactical training.

How Long is Too Long to Remain in SWAT?

Some administrators want a mandatory rotation of SWAT veterans to other duties. That’s a really bad idea.

December 03, 2008  |  by Robert O'Brien - Also by this author

Earlier this year, a controversial report was leaked involving vaunted LAPD SWAT. While complimentary in parts, other portions of the report were highly critical of certain aspects of LAPD SWAT. Especially what the report referred to as SWAT’s “insular” attitude, which it concluded was caused in part when personnel remain in SWAT too long.

The report cited the need for “changes,” including more diversification, oversight, and rotation of personnel. The report recommended mandatory rotation out of SWAT after 10 years, with a one-time five-year extension possible with the chief’s approval. The report cited the benefits of mandatory rotation for SWAT. However, to many observers, the real reason was to eliminate SWAT’s “insular” attitude.

As expected, the LAPD SWAT report touched off a storm of controversy over many of its recommendations, including mandatory rotation.

Allow me to weigh in on this controversy by saying two words: Jim Gnew. So, who exactly is Jim Gnew?

He’s a member of the Cleveland SWAT and may be the longest serving active, full-time SWAT operator anywhere. Jim has been assigned to CPD’s full-time SWAT and Tactical Units since 1973 when I first met him, more than 35 years ago.

As CPD SWAT’s senior operator, Jim’s wealth of experience contributed greatly to the unit’s remarkable record. His experience includes service on an estimated 10,000 SWAT missions, including the following high-profile “big ones”:

• January 4, 1985: Attempted jet hijacking/shooting/hostage situation at Cleveland Hopkins Airport. Jim was point man during SWAT’s hostage rescue assault. The suspect shot him in his vest (bullet then glanced off his knee). The #2 officer shot and neutralized the suspect, and all hostages were rescued unharmed. The CPD SWAT entry team was awarded the NTOA valor award.

• May 9, 2003: Active shooter incident at Case Western Reserve University. Again, Jim was up front throughout the seven-hour running gun battle between the heavily armed suspect and CPD SWAT. The incident ended with the suspect being wounded, captured and convicted. Cleveland SWAT received the NTOA 2003 Unit Citation for Valor.

Prior to joining Tactical and SWAT, Jim also received the Cleveland Police Dept’s Medal of Valor Award for rescuing persons inside a burning home.

Jim’s remarkable 39-year career is about far more than awards and commendations. It’s about the passion and dedication Jim continues to sustain as both police officer and SWAT member. Now that his long SWAT career has come to a close, Jim has been named CPD’s primary tactical trainer for the entire department. He was appointed to this position by the CPD chief, a former longtime SWAT Sergeant who supervised Jim for many years.

I’ve known Jim more than 35 years, many of those in SWAT and Tactical when he was assigned to my squad. From day one, Jim has always displayed the highest devotion and professionalism throughout his entire police and SWAT career.

I point to Jim Gnew as a prime example of why I am against arbitrary mandatory SWAT personnel rotation policies.

I’m also a strong believer in setting SWAT standards and requirements to the highest level possible. So only the “best of the best” can make it into and remain in SWAT. I can assure you that CPD SWAT’s standards and requirements are among the highest anywhere and that Jim Gnew received no “special treatment” whatsoever.

In fact, it was Jim’s accumulated years of injuries that finally caught up to him and prevented him from passing SWAT’s rigorous PFT test, removing him from the team. Injuries, including surgeries, from the constant pounding and physical challenges of being a SWAT officer, including carrying up to 70 pounds of gear. Injuries that most, if not all, SWAT officers sustain during their SWAT careers, especially if they stay in SWAT long enough.

Like all SWAT officers, Jim never once complained about injuries or physical demands of the job, accepting them as part of doing the job. That he was able to stay in “SWAT shape” so many years is both remarkable and amazing.
To those who would advocate arbitrary, mandatory SWAT personnel rotation, I offer a two-words reply: Jim Gnew.

Had such a policy been in place, Jim would have been forced out of SWAT in 1988, a full 20 years of his vast knowledge and experience lost. And for what reason? Certainly not because he soured on SWAT, or couldn’t keep up with the younger troops--who affectionately call him “Grandpa.”

No, arbitrary rotation has nothing to do with the job of SWAT itself. Instead, it’s about the—in my opinion, wrong—belief that staying too long in SWAT results in becoming “insular.”

My question to these advocates, and to SWAT officers everywhere is this. Does Jim Gnew sound “insular” to you? The answer is a resounding "no." Instead, the exact opposite is true. Jim now brings his wealth of tactical knowledge, experience, and enthusiasm to his new role as CPD’s primary tactical trainer.

“Insular,” not hardly, and I venture there are many more “Jim Gnews” out there throughout the SWAT community.

Arbitrary mandatory rotation out of SWAT? A good or bad idea? I say it’s bad. Standards and attitude are what SWAT is about, not an unproven arbitrary number of years in SWAT that might possibly lead to becoming “insular.”

Perhaps, the person who said it best was Ron McCarthy (legendary original LAPD SWAT Team Leader and highly respected SWAT/tactical trainer). Ron was lead instructor at a large SWAT conference I was attending. During his talk, Ron interrupted himself and said he was a fan of “old” SWAT guys because they had “survived” and lent their vast experience to their teams.

Then, Ron pointed directly at me, as an example of an “old SWAT guy.” Then age 49, I considered myself anything but “old”, but I got Ron’s point. And so did everyone else.

I hope your administrators get it, too.

Comments (2)

Displaying 1 - 2 of 2

Jason Mook @ 12/4/2008 7:16 AM

Another fine example to illustrate the point is the legendary Ken Thatcher, LAPD SWAT

tpd223 @ 12/11/2008 12:08 AM

Great article.

I am jealous of Gnew though, I was only able to spend 19years in SWAT on my department, I feel robbed! :-)

Lt. Chuck Haggard
Topeka PD

Join the Discussion

POLICE Magazine does not tolerate comments that include profanity, personal attacks or antisocial behavior (such as "spamming" or "trolling"). This and other inappropriate content or material will be removed. We reserve the right to block any user who violates this, including removing all content posted by that user.

Other Recent Blog Posts

Active Shooters, Gun Control, and Mental Health
If we are truly serious about reducing active shooter deaths, we must stop the political...

Get Your FREE Trial Issue and Win a Gift! Subscribe Today!
Yes! Please rush me my FREE TRIAL ISSUE of POLICE magazine and FREE Officer Survival Guide with tips and tactics to help me safely get out of 10 different situations.

Just fill in the form to the right and click the button to receive your FREE Trial Issue.

If POLICE does not satisfy you, just write "cancel" on the invoice and send it back. You'll pay nothing, and the FREE issue is yours to keep. If you enjoy POLICE, pay only $25 for a full one-year subscription (12 issues in all). Enjoy a savings of nearly 60% off the cover price!

Offer valid in US only. Outside U.S., click here.
Police Magazine