How Cops Get People Killed

Friendly fire. Erratic driving. Improper medical diagnoses. These are but a few officer-involved errors that have resulted in deaths of innocents. That isn't to say that we aren't conscientious professionals. But we do make mistakes.

Author Dean Scoville Headshot

Friendly fire. Erratic driving. Improper medical diagnoses. These are but a few officer-involved errors that have resulted in deaths of innocents. That isn't to say that we aren't conscientious professionals; indeed, as a vocation we still have some room to catch up with the medical profession, which causes some 90,000 fatalities a year. Nor are we particularly apathetic on the matter. More than one of us has recriminated himself for another's death and performed the most sincere self-criticism known to man.

But we do make mistakes.

Perhaps one of the biggest mistakes we can make is getting caught up in the immediacy of the moment, becoming so fixated on a mission at hand that things become blurred at the periphery. Unfortunately, innocent bystanders are often found on the periphery.

We have the collateral responsibility to correctly assess appropriate responses to deadly force threats, remaining conscious of fields of fire and the presence of innocents who may move in and out of the kill zone. This includes the possibility of hitting fellow officers due to crossfire alignments, or not recognizing off-duty or plainclothes officers who are actively engaging suspects. Taking advantage of appropriate cover and concealment can mitigate friendly fire threats, as can alerting officers of one another's presence and granting them the split second it may take for mutual recognition.

Overestimating one's ability to handle a patrol car can lead to a fatal accident. We often perform in an exemplary manner under controlled conditions. But once placed in an uncontrolled arena—replete with sharp corners and oiled pavements, inclement weather, and unpredictable motorists—our skills may prove lacking. While the most common patrol car accidents involve backing maneuvers, most officer-involved fatalities stem from emergent call responses and pursuit driving.

When faced with an individual who's acting strangely, we can also err in not recognizing a dire medical emergency, attributing the person's behavior to some ingested substance instead of a possible diabetic reaction or seizure. This type of miscalculation can result in actions that aggravate the problem instead of resolve it. At such times, remembering the Hippocratic Oath of "First do no harm" is a very good idea.

Arbitrarily ignoring problems or kissing off reports can leave citizens vulnerable to escalating threats. Nowhere is this more pronounced than in matters of domestic discord.

Lack of weapons familiarity and training have also proven fateful, with officers mistakenly deploying traditional shotguns when they thought they were wielding beanbag shotguns.

Not verifying information can find officers serving high-risk warrants at incorrect addresses, precipitating shootings wherein fearful owners unwittingly engage the men and women sworn to protect them.

More than one cop has let a DUI suspect go. Whether the result of his own observation-based detention or a citizen flag-down, an officer's decision to allow a DUI suspect back behind the wheel is one of the most negligent things an officer can do.

Throughout our careers, we face daily challenges to keep the streets of their communities safe. The celebrated motto of the LAPD—To Protect and To Serve—should serve as a reminder to all of us, especially the less service-minded of us, of our obligation to protect. That includes protection not only from the malicious actions of bad guys but from mistakes by ourselves and our fellow officers as well.

About the Author
Author Dean Scoville Headshot
Associate Editor
View Bio
Page 1 of 56
Next Page