Today's Date: Monday, October 13, 2008

Tasers really are safe

10/10/2007 7:12 PM

Steve Rothstein

Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 264

Tasers really are safe


Well, for those of you who did not read the news article on the front page of the site, it seems like there is fairly conclusive proof that Tasers are safe. The NIJ funded a study of 1000 deployments in several departments and found only 3 injuries that required hospitalization. Two of those were head injuries from falling after the Taser was used. One was a person who went to the hospital two days after the Taser and the medical problem could not be shown to be related to the Taser. One death that the autopsy says was not related to the Taser. Story was also published in peer reviewed medical journals.

I am willing to bet there will still be some people who think Tasers kill. They will claim the study had a problem in the methodology or something. They will claim that the death might have been related and the ME bought into the phantom disease known as excited delirium.

But to me, the only thing I see unanswered in this survey has nothing to do with the injury rate. I am still concerned with the overuse of the Taser by poorly trained officers who do not know how to use force properly. And that is not the fault of the Taser.


Story at: 

http://www.policemag.com/News/2007/10/10/Nationwide-Independent-Taser-Study-Results-Suggest-Devices-are-Safe.aspx



REPLY  1 - 6 of 6
12/28/2007 10:53 AM #1

AK94ME

Join Date: December 2007
Posts: 3

RE: Tasers really are safe


Howdy All;

TASER's are the best thing to happen to Law Enforcement since the two-way radio!

9/18/2008 8:06 AM #2

centurion

Join Date: September 2008
Posts: 4

Multi-shot remote stun gun


In Russia have created less-lethal multi-shot remote stun gun

Pull Down Gun reduce the risk of electrical injury

http://pulldowngun.narod.ru/Home.html

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IQITYByDSn0

What do you think?

9/18/2008 4:12 PM #3

Steve Rothstein

Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 264

RE: Tasers really are safe


It looks interesting. I would like more information about how it works (straight charge or pulses like Taser) and whether it keeps sending the charge while you hold the trigger down.

The bad part is if you let go of the trigger, it ejects the cartridges and reloads, so fi I have to re-hit the same person I need a full second shot.

9/19/2008 11:31 PM #4

centurion

Join Date: September 2008
Posts: 4

RE: Tasers really are safe


Main advantages PDG are shown, when it is used for a immobilization of several objects. For a immobilization of several objects it is necessary to shoot quickly. When operator pulls the trigger, the probes are shoot out and electricity is transferred to target. When trigger is released, cartridges are ejected. It is simple.

9/20/2008 10:11 AM #5

Steve Rothstein

Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 264

RE: Tasers really are safe


Yes, but how long does it keep the elctricity flowing when the cartridges are ejected? If they stop as soon as the cartridge leaves the pistol, then it may not be useful for crowds since the person can get back up as soon as I go to shoot the second. One of the proven problems with any conducted energy type weapon is that the person may not comply once the enrgy stops flowing.

Is the energy pulsed like the taser for interference with nerve control or is it just a straight electrical charge like an older style stun gun? How long does it conduct electricity if I have just one subject and hold the trigger down? How long does it conduct electricity if I shoot four or five rapid shots at people in a crowd?

I see some advantages, especially for crowd control, but I would need to know more about how it works, like those questions. After I get those answers, I might want to see more info or not.

9/22/2008 6:41 PM #6

wolfva

Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 96

RE: Tasers really are safe


I'd also like to see how it stacks up against the TASER shotgun shells. Sounds like it's a similar concept.

Post reply

You Spoke. We Listened. The NEW PoliceMag.com

Hot Products
  • October 2008 - Product Patrol

    SpatialKey
    Universal Mind

    GIS-based data application SpatialKey not only quickly gathers information on suspected criminal incidents and provides them immediately to responding officers, it also tracks patrol locations and monitors their travel routes and speeds, which can be altered to help save fuel and better serve the community.

    View More

  • October 2008 - Product Patrol

    Small Rechargeable LED Light
    Essential Gear

    Essential Gear’s compact Spotlight flashlight measures under two inches and weighs just 1.6 ounces, making it a handy tool. Whether it’s viewing ID or locating your keys, the 0.5-watt LED Spotlight will always be at its peak power.

    View More

e-News Sign-up

PoliceMag.com offers a selection of FREE e-newsletters. Get news and information about topics important to you.

  • OnTarget - Sent to you weekly. General law enforcement news.
  • Firearms & Tactics - Sent to you every other week. Training tips and news on the gun market.
  • Patrol Tactics - Sent to you weekly. Timely information for street cops.
  • Recruit - Sent to you monthly. Advice for the aspiring officer.
  • SWAT - Sent to you weekly. Techniques for tactical team members and leaders.
  • Trainers and Training - Sent to you monthly. Tips, techniques, and advice to help you improve your training and stretch your training dollar.

COPYRIGHT © 2008 POLICE Magazine. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.